Blue Cross of Texas says drug maker encouraged prescribing meds off label
Insurer sues Pfizer for paying kickbacks to docs
Seeded on Fri Jun 11, 2010 4:15 PM EDT (msnbc.com)
— Filed under: health, health-care, general-news, industries, law-and-order, financial-services, health-care-industry


Why are the Drs exempt from this....Don't tell me they didn't know what was going on.....
#1
This should give you a little in sight into just "why". Select the link, scroll down & follow the RELATED tabs.
Here's a clue. 3 guesses.
The first two don't count.
The third starts with M, Ends with Y, And makes the world go around.
I always thought those kickbacks were a huge conflict of interest.
I'm always suspicious of those three piece suits with the leather brief cases in the doctor's offices. I'll be sitting there for a half hour, they'll go in and out in five minutes or less. Just long enough to hand over the pile of cash I guess.
Bring on the lawsuits. Prosecute some doctors while you're at it.
When you hear about Medicare and Medicaid fraud ---- this is some of what they are talking about. Slowly, but surely, drug companies are putting the names of physicians to whom they are giving "gifts." And if your physician then tells you that all he gets are some pens and magnets, you will see the dollar value of the pens and magnets as well as any cash, trips, lunches, etc. You will be shocked at the list when you look at it.
Here's some MORE of what they are talking about.
Gourmet catered lunches & dinners (for 1-500) where "colleague physicians" discuss ways attendees can work the discussed product (drug) into the scripts for their patients. The speakers can make $1000-$15000 PER LECTURE and may be selected to do 3 or more per year.
Trips (travel, accomodations AND PER DIEM) to conferences where these lectures take place HOURLY.
It was said during the Health Care "Reform" legislative process that there were 10-15 pharma lobbyist in DC for every legislator. That translates into 10,000-15,000 SALESMEN for 1000 customers.
Pharma makes BILLIONS on these drugs every YEAR and include litigation, damage awards, federal fines, and physician's marketing fees in the pricing models and cost benefit analysis BEFORE THEY EVER cap a sample pillbottle to give to your local doctor.
Ya, its funny how health care doesnt really concern the patient anymore, just the money that doctors, drug makers , and insurance shysters get. Everything is OK as long as they make money and even then they still have to fight over it. Meanwhile, F##K the patient....
Why don't you guys become doctors? Give up the remaining years of your youth, get a couple hundred grand in the hole, and then have a bunch of A holes tell you how much you should make and what you should do with your time and life. Sounds like a dream to me.
Some fields should never have been for profit because the abuse potential is too high. I like the part where the corporation "agreed" to billions in civil and criminal fines. If a corporation can be entitled to status as an individual, then that corporation should be subject to the same penalties as an individual, including death of that corporation. I would laugh to see it printed that any "individual" named in a civil or criminal complaint would "agree to civil and criminal penalties" - that would mean mean an individual had some ability to deny same and that's not happening anywhere; is it?
So your choice to be a doctor allows you to UNETHICALLY GRAFT as much as you can in collusion with drug companies promoting UNTESTED UNSAFE medications causing death?
Welcome to the REAL world doc.
Ummm FINALLY! the attention really needs to be on the drug companies. They are the ones being the dirtiest in the health biz. Doctors are really abusing their business by accepting bribery money to prescribe a particular drug. You should truly be ashamed of yourself if your doing that. The whole reason why you went to medical school to become a doctor was to help people and save lives, not help drug companies make more money and lining your pockets as well. What a disgrace.
the drug companies had a "behind closed doors" deal with obama and friends during the health care debate. so they werent touched. also you should consider that every drug that is trialed to get approval by the fda. that trial is bought and paid for by the drug company who makes it. millions of dollars to get a "good result" with minimal side effects. most studies dont include anybody with any health problems. dont want any normal people spoiling the results.
The Dr.s are exempt because they didn't do anything wrong! If a drug company says, "prescribe this drug for this illness based on this research", why wouldn't we prescribe it if the research was OK. Drug companies pay for business just like every other business. Dr.s are the customer in this case. Why does the government need to get involved in EVERY SINGLE thing? Next someone is going to say Blue Cross deserves their money back. Holy @*($! Are you crazy? Those people are f'in crooks! We would all be better off just paying cash for our Dr visits and get rid of the so-called "insurance" industry. There is a reason that ALL insurance companies eventually make money if they just play the odds. They are like one BIG Las Vegas casino. And they are in the business of screwing Americans.
You people have no f'in idea what you are talking about. You think Dr.s are crooks? I'll bet every one of you are broke and just want the "Fat Cats" to get something taken away. Idiots!! Physicians are the worst business people on earth. If they truly knew how much power they have as a collective body they could all be millionaires overnight! The reason they don't is because they draw the line when it comes to taking money over helping someone! What other profession do you know of that does that? What do you losers do for a living? Criticize rich people?
If you AREN'T part of the solution...
you know the rest.
LOL, but kickbacks are what makes the world go around. From big business to big politics, its the American way!
Lou
http://www.anon-posting.at.tc
Sad, but true.
How else could you explain the relationship between the MMS and the oil companies?
Grease my pocket and I'll sign any permit.
Prosecute them all!!!
Prosecuting would only give the fines to the government. It is more profitable and less time consuming for them to get "contributions"
Yeh. it's the American way, and that's why America is dieing a slow and painful death.
I don't often have anything positive to say about insurance companies, but BRAVO!
The only reason that the insurance company was upset was because it was cutting into their bottom line. Otherwise it would have been ok with them. Enough said!!
So many stupid people in the world. Its not the fact that the insurance company was losing money. you just made up that reason out of no where. How can the insurance company be missing out? They get their money either way, they don't have to go to the drug company for it. They go to you and your employer for it. You should explain your reasoning rather than just posting an opinion.
A scumbag health insurance company suing a scumbag drug manufacturer. It's like 2 parasite infested turds fighting over which one smells worse.
Yeah, I wonder why healthcare is so expensive?
OMG - too funny........
another form of civilized cannabalism.........
Great comment, jon.
Don't forget the scumbag doctors in the middle of it. You can't bribe an honest person.
I agree. I worked in the medical field for years battling insurance company denials and "mistakes" of non payment. Just like casinos, insurance companies and drug companies didn't become so big and get built giving money away.
As I understand it, insurance is collective action to prevent catastrophe. Where does a middleman/shareholder fit the model? Yeah, the problems are really basic.
You mean to tell me Pfizer would do something pfishy? I thought they were all about being pfair. Someone pfound them at pfault? You gotta be pf-cking with me!!!!? Better bend over Pfizer boys, you're about to meet your new boypfriends in pfederal prison!!!!
Never happen (but should, along with insurance and the rest of corporate big wigs) They will settle with a secret agreement and NO ADMITTANCE OF GUILT. That is the way it works.
Don't you people realize that the AMA and the Pharmacuetical conglomerates have been in cahoots for eons? Why are our insurance priemiums so high? Guess what lemmings; you allowed them to do it.
Another effective rake on the economy.
this is interesting how they are filing suit after hearing about another lawsuit, but actually being unaware of the 'kickbacks' actually happening. A hear say lawsuit - should get thrown out quickly. Having been in pharma over 12 years, and recently being laid off thanks to Obamacare, I have yet to see a kickback. We are in and out of the office in 5 minutes not handing out bundles of cash - a crazy remark - but to actually try to talk to the doctor. Their schedules are so backlogged that it generally consists of a reminder of the product name, dosing and indication along with managed care coverage. They sign and off they go. It's interesting how pharma is made out to be bad guys, while the drugs they develop keep people alive, improve life and allow people to do more with various diseases holding them from life. I'm not a cheerleader or drinking kool aid, but if people really understood what the pharma companies deal with they might think differently. Most pharma companies have a massive leagal team to manage due to hundred's of lawsuits filed against them because someone wants to get a few million because they had an allergice reaction to a medicine. So, if I get an itchy nose I should sue company x for a million bucks because I feel they can pay it. The basis of the lawsuits is amazing most of the time. Due to the sue happy place we live it, those costs like any other business, are passed onto the consumer. Thank your sue happy friends for the high cost of medicine :) . Oh well, no worries, under Obamacare 2 million jobs in the industry will be lost with sales reps and scientists. So in 10 to 12 years when there are no new drugs in the marketplace and people are wondering why we don't have cures of medications to control certain diseases, remember to badmouth those evil pharma companies for failing you yet again. How dare they run a business that actually profits? I know any of you would be more than happy to open up a business and lose money all day long and they go bankrupt - that would be sensible and fulfilling...no?
Oh please! These doctors are passing out these drugs like candy! Literally experimenting on patients with them..............And THEY HAVE ABSOLUTELY NO KNOWLEDGE OF THE SIDE EFFECTS OR INTERACTIONS OF THESE DRUGS and THEY ARE/HAVE KILLED PEOPLE with their negligence! Here's how it should work:
Experiment on the employee's who created the drug..............let them take it for 20 years before the FDA approves it and then and only then, should any drug make it to market!
As far as a 'cure' for an illness/disease............Medicines are not 'designed to cure' an illness........they are designed to control/help with the syptoms of an illness/disease. Finding an actual 'cure' would put them out of business.
This sounds like a typicial sales person, trying to sell BULL @!$%#.
Biz, you said you lost your job because of Obamacare. If we have Obamacare in this country, as you claim, how come I am still without health insurance? I had to drop my coverage 5 years ago after the premium went from $500. per month to almost $900. per month in 3 short years. And that was with a $10,000. deductible. You may have lost your job, but it certainly wasn't because of any OBAMACARE.
excellent comment biz!!!
damn tired... would you be willing to create an experimetal drug and then test it on yourself? You are a complete baffoon. If that were the case, then no new drugs would be created that help us out tremendously. That is how you liberals think though, you think that no matter what crazy ideas you have, there will always be someone there to follow it and take care of you. You start implenting just pure insane rules and regulations and you will have a society of medocrity, just like you lunatics want.
Yep typical salesperson commenting on what actually happens...I would like to know if any of you have been a medical sales rep before or currently? Then you can say all you want, but some of these comments are so far from the truth it's comical, but sad that people believe it to be true. Anyhow, someone chimed in about Obamacare and the loss of jobs - and yep it's true - not only did the industry inform us sales folk of what would happen, but good Ol' MSNBC had it in their featured "Daily Medicine" they put up each day while the debate was on. I also read the bill - all damn 2000 + pages, because I'm weird I actually like to know what I'm talking about (Darn pharma sales people cause I'm supposed to be an evil liar), and it clearly spelled out that there will be little room for pharma marketing and or sales. The incentive to conduct Research and Development (R&D) will also be taken away. If you hand enough things out to people the incentive to do something get's lost as well. By the comments on this thread it's clear most don't know what they are talking about. I've sat in waiting rooms with patients giving me dirty looks and the like - but boy they sure are glad when they get three months worth of free samples to take care of their issue. Wow and the doctor didn't write a script and I didn't get anything for it. Shame on me for being so generous. How many billions, yes billions, of free medications are given out every year for patients from the pharma industry? Try 2 billion folks - that's a lot of millions. Also someone rationalized that they have no insurance due to the pharma industry? Not sure how that connection happened, but whatever floats your boat. For the most part, people that have such hatred towards the pharma industry are usually jealous because we make good money and we know that being successful and making a good living is a bad thing nowadays. Unless of course that shoe was on their foot they would be OK with it. Funny how that works.
and David...Obamacare has begun, you should read about it - it started last month. The reason layoffs are happening is because companies are looking at what they will have to pay into the system and then looking at what they need to be sustainable. The golden goose theory at work by the government (Democrats) that is until the goose decides to stop laying those eggs. So yes, I was laid off because of Obamacare as our company stated that due to the new bill and it's effect upon the medical industry they wouldn't be able to stay afloat with the number of employees they had. Not trying to argue, but you should read up before you state why I was or wasn't let go. I again am wondering though who will be paying for all this great care moving forward as these are good paying jobs that put a lot into the tax base. The last three years I have personally paid over $30,000 in taxes for all these great programs - you can take that away now, times the 2 million who are getting laid off.
one last rant and then I'm done! The Doctors ask all day along about off label use and we tell them you can't go there. They gloat over and over about how they are using it for this and that - again we tell them you can't go there. We deliver the medicine to the Doctors, they deliver it to you - how they choose to use it is up to them entirely - but again, the connection is somehow made that the drug companies are bad. The logic is flawed it seems.
Yeah, I'm your savior. That's why I have you bent over taking it. Insurance is an abuse of trust as it exists.
Yo all stockholders into that "free enterprise" thing, how's that government mandated insurance dividend? The problems are very basic.
Bad Business Bad Government helping you through your day. Equality..
Plenty of kickback money but no money to retain workers - just lay 'em off!!!
Oh, and no money for snake bite antivenin. So just stop making it and if someone dies from a snakebite or is left disabled, oh well!!! The technology is there, Pfizer...WHERE IS YOUR ACCOUNTABILITY TO PATIENTS???!!!!
Let us call our so-called health care system, our Legal Drug Cartel and Drs, our street corner pushers.. Profits over people, miracle drugs with deadly side-effects Safer, more effective medicines scrapped. canceled bought out because drug companies can't make a huge profit. We're all rats in a cage.. Who supports medical research. Medical Schools.. you guessed Big Pharma.. What a shameful system. Should be called Sick care, instead of healthcare, or maybe moneycare! Who cares!!
Good. Let's expose more of this white collar criminality that pervades the 'legal' drug industry.
Kickbacks to doctors? Come on! Big drug companies know that should be reserved only for politicians.
Why aren"t the doctors being charged. The only thing the food and drug was concerened about was getting their fine money, what about protecting the public from ALL the uncareing crocked doctors out there.
Hey my ex wife is allergic to a common chemical used for heart problems. In the fifties before they used this common drug they used digitalis the medical community says it is to coastly to used today can not make a profit so if your allergic thats your problem, The great caring drug companies
I noticed the insurer did not sue the Doctors !!! Why not, oh thats right they don't give a rats ass about the public.
I remember back in college, many moons ago, taking a Health class.. The Prof. asked the class, " What is the single best reason for the increased lifespan in the 2oth century"? I remember the first answer, better drugs.. He said no. Another raised there hand and said more doctors.. He said No.. This went for a while till he finally gave us the answer, " Better sanitation and sewers". So we moderns should be thanking our garbage men, plumbers and Water Authority. The Age of MD worship maybe over
The doctors who prescribed these medicines are more guilty than the drug companies. They are THE DOCTOR! Drug companies have a loyalty to the bottom line, but doctors are supposed to have a duty to their patients.
Any doctor who took kickbacks to prescribe drugs off label should be prosecuted and lose their license.
I think, as a physician, I would rather have the drug companies bring down the cost of the meds rather than try shady marketing techniques like offering kickbacks to docs. The kickbacks suck by the way. They certainly aren't worth risking a breach of ethics.
As for those of you who are so quick to "hate on" physicians; in what other profession do you know of is the professional viewed as a crook for trying to make as much money as possible with the academic degree that took 8 years AFTER high school plus 3-7 yrs of minimum wage OJT prior to making ANY money. Even greedy physicians probably end up doing more charity work in a year than ALL of you do in a lifetime.
And I love the WebMD comment above. Seriously, when are people going to figure out that physicians don't give a flip what you read about this or that...especially on the internet? Do you really think medicine is something that you can just "pick up" by reading a few articles? I wish I could charge patients the way attorneys do. I'd let you talk all day long. Oh yeah...that's right, if your insurance didn't cover it I'd never see a penny; because you think it's your right to have me take care of you.
Give me a break!!!
Drs are figuring things out quickly though. We won't be the worst businessmen for long. Soon enough, physicians are going to realize just how powerful they really are. Pretty soon, if you aren't paying cash, you are F'd. Pay first and then file your own damn insurance claim.
No surprise!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
right
Speaking of drugs, does anyone know of a doctor in California or Arizona who will give my 12 month old son the MMR vaccine individually and not in the combined form? I know autism debate, but I don't trust government or pharms and would rather be safe than sorry. Thanks.
I'd like to see the drug company get a break from prosecution in return for the names of the doctors who took the kickbacks.
Our family physician has never tried to push a drug on anyone in our family. He is one upstanding man in our small western AZ town. Unlike another doctor here in town who has been fined mega thousands for inappropriate prescribing/kickbacks
I think that we should just get rid of doctors and let all you guys who are so intelligent on the matter be responsible for your own health. That way, you won't have to worry about whether or not you chose an unscrupulous doctor or not. You guys can start relying on web md and that way you won't have to pay extravagent healthcare costs. Watch out though, MRI machines are pretty darn expensive. You guys obviously know what is best though, so you'll be fine. Good Luck.
Great comment Mark D!! I agree, people seem to know more about medication, treatment and protocol than the Docs, RN's and hospitals. It's not about common business sense, it's all about what feels good.
I'm all for paying doctors well. It's just the profit denied from them by owners as costs are driven up by business parasites and fiat debt. I think we're in Hell. Reality could be anything we make, and we're XXXXed. As long as it's about money it's going to be violent.
Hope you guys are good at chemistry too and can formulate your own drugs. That way we can get rid of those evil big pharm companies that save millions of lives annually. According to you liberals, damned the costs when it comes to peoples lives. It just seems you abandon your creedo when it goes against what you actually believe.
You're rather hot under the collar, there, Mark D.
Do you think it's ethical for doctors to prescribe a medication for something other than what it was designed for, without any idea of the side effects?
screminmimi it happens quite often with doctors - they do it on their own accord and there are many cases where saved lives.
If you think THIS is criminal...just wait until Obamacare gets started (and I am hoping it won't get funded). If it takes hold, you "ain't seen nothin' yet.".
I suspected my psychiatrist was getting kickbacks when he so adamantly prescribed Geodon. It doesn't surprise me that Geodon is one of the falsely marketed drugs in this article. I talked to my therapist who works in the same building and she said there is no way he could be getting kickbacks, she explained the process involved with the salesmen or whatever they are come in and it sounded very careful and elaborate. She has no reason to lie, but I doubt this place is immune to having a doctor receive kickbacks. I still suspect my doctor is getting them, I told him I've been worse on the drug than without it but he refuses to authorize me going off of it, and the withdrawals are awful so I'm stuck. How do I ask my doctor if he's getting kickbacks without him freaking out? He has a huge ego that fires off explosively when tampered with.
go find a new doc....this current doc of your's is holding you drug/hostage
Really?! Are you kidding me?! We are in need of Physicians around the globe because no one wants the carry the hours, the burden, mounting debt or the risk to your own health anymore and you are blaming the doctors for taking some extra money?! It is up to the Pharma company to make sure that their product is save and up to the doctor to prescribe the right meds to the patient. Due to Doctors being very cautious about prescribing something new and unknown ( by all means they risk having to relocate their entire family out of town or losing their livelihood) they have to be almost forces into prescribing something new. If this method of kick backs was used in the right way and watched more closely this could actually work and get new better products on the market much faster. But there always has to be this one bad apple...! Ruining all the rest! The sooner everyone realizes that not Everyone fits in the same box the better off we are going to be.