Chronic Lyme disease is the newest pidgeon hole for patients who used to "have" fibromyalgia, and that "disease" was the follow up to chronic fatigue syndrome. Most of these people are not ill, they just complain. There is no objective measurable test for any of these so called diseases/syndromes. You must have a diagnosis to get insurance to pay for the treatment, otherwise you are NOT ill.
The issue IS the testing. Standard Lyme disease testing is only 65% accurate; this standard of testing would not be accepted for any other ailment. Imagine a doctor giving you a diagnosis of cancer, for example, based on a test that's 65% accurate. And just for the record, I have never experienced chronic lyme disease myself, or any of the other "complainer" diseases.
I can be reached for comment and I believe I have Lyme disease that periodically flares. I've read the opinion on both side of the debate and the opposition offers nothing to account for my recurring symptoms.
The latest, and worst, is an extremely painful cyst in my knee. These cysts have been proven to be caused by and harbor Lyme spirochetes. Despite 5 month living with constant pain and a reduction in mobility that prevents me from working--my job requires agility at the very least--I cannot find a doctor to treat the cyst.
Kris you're giving the ELISA test too much accuracy. According to the American College of Pathologists, it is accurate merely 45% of the time.
I recently tested double positive for lyme on the standard Elisa and Western Blot tests and the CD 57 and have been chronically ill for over 15 years. What I have found is that doctors are now agreeing that fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue are multiple infection syndrome and in addition to a person possibly having lyme bacteria they most often have an overload of several coexisting infections such as Epstein Barr and others. As far as this not being real, I can assure you I would do ANYTHING to get better and ride my horses and be active with my kids again!
As for testing, it is true that adrenal and thyroid issues accompany multiple infection syndrome and are testable, but another good test is the tilt table test. Many doctors are finding their fibromyalgia patients will have quite a significant drop in blood pressure upon rising. (Mine drops 20 pts. currently.) Furthermore, one can also easily examine blood under a dark field microscope and see the lyme spirochetes.
Lastly, multiple infection syndrome including lyme disease also can cause mitochondrial (the batteries of the cells) failure issues which can account for the inability to have quality energy and the need to physically recharge after any exertion.
For those who are ill, DO NOT GIVE UP and do not let anyone tell you that this is in your head (as some of my doctors did initially)! It sucks that our medical system is so political and money oriented and not focused on quality whole person care. Nevertheless, there truly are millions of people suffering from an overload of infections (and toxins) who can recover as long as they receive the right care and support! One might also want to google Transfer Factors (the good stuff from egg yolk, colostrom, and immune supporting nutrients) as well as they have been showing significant results for years in helping chronically ill people recover their energy and function. I WISH GOOD HEALTH TO YOU ALL! Life is too short to suffer through it!
Hmmm..... I wonder how my nephew feels about all the problems he's had for the past 10 years being just a figment of his imagination. He used to be very active, doing triathlons, road races, etc. Now he struggles at less than half the energy he had, not to mention the physical problems, headaches, etc. But, I guess it is good to know that all he has to do is think positive and it will go away.
Independent Thought, that doesn't rule out some of the more than 100 different types of arthritis.
I have three types, and each of them affect just about every part of my body. But they don't affect every part of my body all the time. Some days, and for that matter, some hours, one joint, one body part, may be causing me a lot of pain. Sometimes it's another joint or another part. Sometimes it's all over, and sometimes everything is a bit sore but nothing is painful.
This is what happens when you have even one type of arthritis. Yes, that includes having "only" osteoarthritis, but in more than one joint. And if even one of your types of arthritis is inflammatory, then it can take anywhere from weeks (aggressive rheumatoid arthritis) to years, even at times, decades (ie, psoriatic arthritis), for the damage to show up on x-rays.
Been there, done that, and I'd like to throw out the #$)(#*$ T-shirt.
Thousands of patients have reported successfully using antibiotics for conditions including rheumatoid arthritis, scleroderma, juvenile rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, dermatomyositis, ankylosing spondylitis, Lyme disease, Reiter's syndrome, mixed connective tissue disease, fibromyalgia and psoriatic arthritis. Results of an international survey of patients documented dramatic results including relief of pain, the lessening of swollen joints and an overall successful return of quality of life.
I'm no fan of the pharmaceutical industry, but some antibiotics really help.
What works best for me is Colloidal Silver. No side effects, kills candida infections, and works better in general than any antibiotic for me for "chronic" Lyme Disease and "CFS".
I was on a powerful IV antibiotic called Rocephin, and I hate to say it, but I think a good Colloidal Silver is more effective.
But that being said, there are pharmaceuticals to treat and prevent yeast infections. Diflucan and Nystatin to name a couple.
So what's the proper solution? Inject steroids for the rest of their life for all these "auto-immune" diseases? Sure your body may have developed antibodies against your own cells, but how does that prove there isn't an underlying infectious agent at the root cause?
There's a lot we don't know, and more that we don't want to acknowledge.
So instead of using antibiotics for a potential disease remission, we should compromise our immune system with steroids?
Remicade has been my saving grace, but I am one of the lucky ones who have insurance. It bothers me to know there are people who have that kind of pain and can't get this medicine.
I was diagnosed as having fibromyalgia, although it is just a name for a collection of symptoms, I was instructed to take anti-inflammatory, anti-anxiety and anti-depressants as treatment. Goodness. Didn't fill the scripts. I moved to alternative care at that point in time. I did test positive on the Lymes test CD 57, which is covered by insurance, via an MD who focus's on finding the cause not treating symptoms. I used glutathione to detox, supported my adrenals and thryoid, with great results.
Anyone who has fatigue, speech issues, brain fog, aching, headaches, etc. needs to ensure their adrenals are well (possibly needing better sleep, supplements, hormone therapy and reduction of stressers), and more importantly thyroid function testing. Dr. Lowe (google his work) has done extensive work with fibro, chronic fatigue, and has found hypothryoid (BTW: standard normal lab ranges are too broad) as often the underlying issue. Once I got on the correct dosage of armour thyroid(with both T3 and T4), and a TSH range close to 1.5, all my issues went away.
Was it only adrenal and thyroid issues or chronic lymes? Maybe the lymes created the adrenals and thyroid issue, or not? Personally, I really don't care, now that I feel great.
I found a doctor who doesn't believe he is God and actually listens to his patients. The only thing that accounts for my constellation of symptoms is Lyme disease. I'm on my third course of antibiotics in 5 months and, aside from my knee, I'm starting to feel improvement.
The lazy docs are the ones who won't listen to their patients and want an easy, tidy quick fix.
jkatzw, Lyme disease is NOT the only illness that accounts for those symptoms. That's my point. The list of all of the possible symptoms of "chronic" Lyme disease mirrors the lists of some other problems, including some of the less-well known types of arthritis.
The lazy doctors are the ones who listen to their patients and don't want to understand that the patient has self-diagnosed by searching the internet for a name of something that seems to fit their symptoms. I'm not saying that you necessarily did that, but did you have in mind that you had a particular problem when you first saw that doctor? Even that can influence the diagnosis of a lazy doctor because it influences what you say to that doctor. t points that doctor in the direction of your untrained opinion.
My husband received a positive lyme diagonosis 4 years ago. He had a rash and a high fever. After the recommended treatment we were told he was cured, but no tests were run to prove this. Since then he developed afib (irregular heartbeat) which is being treated. He has also gone through 6 weeks of physical therapy on his shoulder. The pain can come and go and the therapy was not successful. His hips, knees, and feet have also become almost crippling on certain days. The drugs that his doctor's prescribed have not appeared to work, and through all of the doctor visits we had asked if lymes could be a factor and NO one would re-test him. Last month we went to a llmd (lyme literate, medical doctor) who finally retested him, and yes he has active lymes! It is difficult not to resent the attitude of the traditional medical community, including the author of this article, with what our experience has been.
There is such a thing as infective arthritis, and there is such as thing as reactive arthritis. Both, if not properly treated, will continue to cause pain.
So again, what did his rheumatologist have to say??
Rediagnosed and Ind Thought, I hope you have both found at least pallative measures. Gentle massage also helps and if you're not allergic I'd try arnica and or sweet birch essential oils added to the massage oil. See an aromatherapist for a good massage mixture of not more than 30 drops total essential oil per ounce of carrier oil ( I have much experience and education in this). Use sparingly and test for allergies first.
I had Lyme disease when I was 14. I was on a Boy Scout camping trip about 20 miles from Lyme, CT, and found a few ticks of various types crawling on me (but never noticed any feeding) during the course of the trip. I developed a rash soon after the trip, which evolved into a classic bullseye rash over the next day or two, then I got two or three more elsewhere on my body. The bullseye rash is the single most reliable symptom used to diagnose Lyme. My pediatric doctor didn't believe it was Lyme, but my mom made him give me doxycycline for it, which I took for 9 days. The rash went away, though I did develop a fever.
Now I'm 33. I've had issues with fatigue, depression, persistent headache, and cognitive function ("brain fog" would be an appropriate description) since I was an adolescent (soon after contracting Lyme). These issues developed slowly over time, and often would go through cycles of getting worse & better. Last year they finally got bad enough (mostly the fatigue and cognitive issues) where I realized that I was having trouble even doing basic tasks at work, and never had the energy to go to the gym any more. I suspected Lyme and sought treatment for it. I found an LLMD to test and treat me for Lyme. I had numerous tests done (iGeneX Lyme & coinfection blood tests, CD-57 NK, and others). The Lyme tests repeatedly showed a few weak or indeterminate positives on bands specific for Lyme, and a positive on the common 41 kPa band). The CD-57 showed rather low counts (98 once, then 64 the second time) of NK cells. I had *no* test results (past or present) that were positive for Lyme.
Based on these results, my history, and my clinical symptoms, my LLMD treated me for Lyme disease with several antibiotics over the course of 11 months. Zithromax, Metronidazole, Doxycycline, Penicillin-G, Rifampin, Mepron, and Alinia. I was on three or more of these simultaneously for at least six months, and on five for the final few months. I tracked my symptoms carefully, several times per day for the entire period. I would occasionally show significant improvement for up to a few days, but overall, I did not get any better, and (if anything) felt worse.
I went for an expensive second opinion evaluation at Columbia Medical Center in May, 2010. Based on their evaluation, and the fact that I hadn't improved after 11 months of antibiotics, they strongly suggested that I stop the antibiotics and that I probably didn't have Lyme. Shortly before this, one of my other doctors had the idea to check me for food allergies and gluten sensitivity. My results showed broad spectrum food allergies (dairy, soy, eggs, nuts, beef, and others), as well as several indicators for gluten sensitivity. I can't be sure if the allergies were caused/triggered by the antibiotics (see "Leaky Gut"), or if they were there from before, and possibly the root cause. I wish I'd been tested for these before the antibiotics. Apparently food allergies and gluten sensitivity can cause the same symptoms I've been having.
I've since seen other doctors (an endocrinologist to check my thyroid function, and an infectious disease specialist to review my other results). Neither returned any significant results (I have no diseases and my thyroid function is fine), and they both thought I has been improperly treated with antibiotics. I'm still seeking a root cause, but I'm currently focusing on maintaining an allergen-free, low-sugar diet, and repairing the damage to my GI system done by the antibiotics.
YMMV of course, but to anyone who thinks they might have "chronic Lyme", I'd strongly advise them to eliminate all other likely causes before considering treatment for it. Once you start treating chronic Lyme, it's very difficult to figure out when to stop. They tell you it could take months or years to get better. Months or years of antibiotics will do great harm to your body, and it's difficult to understand exactly what that means until you've done it. Plus, what happens when you've taken months or years of antibiotics, and you still haven't improved significantly? When do you stop?
Watch out for chronic Lyme diagnosis/treatment. I'm not saying it doesn't exist (even though this article strongly implies that), but it's easy to go down that road and waste a ton of time and money treating something you don't have, based solely on vague symptoms and best guesses. Not only this, you're *not* treating what you really might have wrong with you during that whole time, and you're also doing great harm to your body.
PS - Dr. Fallon at Columbia Medical Center told me that he has experimental evidence that the CD-57 NK test (commonly used to support a Lyme diagnosis) is completely useless. Between a healthy control group and a carefully selected Lyme-positive group, his research team found no significant difference in CD-57 results. Furthermore, they found that the CD-57 results were highly variable, often changing significantly even from hour to hour. They are in the process of publishing these results and conclusions, if they haven't already.
Pseudothink, these are the results that you get when you have an open mind about something as controversial as "chronic" Lyme disease. Good for you.
The tests for Lyme disease don't test for the presence of the bug but for the presence of the antibodies that a person who has been exposed to the bug has developed. That's all that they can do. They can't even tell if those antibodies developed in the last week or more than decade ago.
Here's an example of the equivalent to that test. Rubella is known as a "childhood disease" but if you happen to contract it while you're pregnant, it can do serious harm to the fetus. But, there is a vaccine against it. Your doctor can tell if you need this vaccine by running a blood test that checks for antibodies to rubella. Those antibodies can have developed at any time in the past. But you don't show the antibodies, and you're a woman of child-bearing age, the vaccine is advisable. It's the same concept, and it measures only for the presence of an antibody. It can't tell you how long that antibody has been present.
I don't see a reference in your post to a rheumatologist. So, arrange to see one, because there are types of arthritis that can explain your lingering symptoms. And if you have seen one, get a second opinion. It's your right.
Thanks rpearlston! I've heard the suggestion to see a rheumatologist before, but given that I've run out of things to investigate for the moment, I'm more interested now. I'm just worried that I'd show up for the appointment, explain my symptoms (fatigue, cognitive difficulty, headache, tinnitus), and the doctor would just ask me why I thought he could help me with them. I don't have an answer for that, nor any clue about what tests he might do that would help. I don't have significant joint pain or joint-related problems that I'm aware of, but I suspect there is more to rheumatology than that? Perhaps it's just the result of inflammation caused by some sort of autoimmune problem?
Pseudothink, as an arthritis patient myself, I can guarantee you that those symptoms are common to many types of arthritis.
Yes, there is more to rheumatology than just explaining joint and joint-related pain. There are more than 100 different types of arthritis, and most of them have little to nothing to do with joint pain. Most, in fact, are auto-immune disorders, and they seem to need an environmental "trigger" of some sort. For you, that may well have been Lyme disease.
Do you best to ensure that the rheumatologist that you see is working in a rheumatology clinic at a teaching hospital. These doctors are clincian/researchers, and are constantly moving that "cutting edge" forwards.
Remember that you don't need a clue as to which tests any doctor will run. Your role as a patient is to be as honest as you can be with your personal and family histories, with your reactions to the physical exam, and with your answers to the questions that any doctor will then pose. Based on all of that, a doctor will decide which tests, both imaging and lab, should be run in order to assist in finding your diagnosis. And that can take a long time. We see that process in a very, very condensed version on the show "House", but it can take years. And everything that gets ruled out is actually a step forward simply because the diagnosis of less-well known problem is about ruling out the more common of the potential explanations. Doctors, after all, are trained to think horses, not zebras, when they hear hoof beats.
Let me summarize that article in a few short words.
There is a very small number of doctors who are too lazy to look for any other health challenges.
That's it. That the article summarized in 18 words, one sentence.
The thing is that there are lots of health challenges with lists of symptoms that mirror the list of "chronic" Lyme disease symptoms. Being able to say, "yes, I have every one of those symptoms" or even , "yes, I have some of these symptoms" does not make the diagnosis "chronic" Lyme disease. Do your jobs, doctors, because as things stand now, the few of you who can't be bothered to do so have also forgotten about that part of the Hypocratic oath that says "first do no harm".
And to jklaser, FM patients are NOT chronic whiners. In fact, there are tests that prove this diagnosis. But a functional MRI is extremely expensive and not available in most places, and a lumbar puncture (spinal tap) is incredibly painful.
From reading all your comments and eyeballing the article, I would say a portion of you have got "the Worm". Toxocariasis.
However nobody mentioned scrotum swelling or blow-outs nor breathing trouble and coughing fits. With a good sized infestation (millions) sinuses are first , lungs are second and reproductive gear is third on where they affect/effect (attack), depending on how they entered you. Listlessness , fatigue, brainFog, depression, milky film on an eye or eyes, anger at Doctors....are all symptoms. If you regularily wake up semiNauseous or have hour(s) long coughing bouts in the middle of the night, if your inner ear is itching alot and your head aches daily, if your teeth are periodically sore and when removed the gum is reluctant to heal, I would recommend another professional exam.
If that option is no longer open (you are broke) ......Dip a cotton swab in 70% alcohol and clean out one (both) of your ears, look at the swab under a good light w/a jewelers loop and if you see any tiny blue or red or brown or green or translucent threads..............get a name brand inhaler and a bottle of "Clarkia" parasite cleanse. The difference between "the Worms" and fiber is that you can pull the creatures apart w/your fingers while fibers you cannot.
If you are male and are infested be prepared for a testicular swelling and blow-out. Ladies , I-m not so sure about. Hope this info helps one/some of you, I wish I'd-a got it 12 years ago.
I am convinced my mother-in-law has end stage Lyme's Disease. She now lives in dementia care facility with next to none short term memory. For many years she has had joint pain that was dismissed as "You've got to expect that. You're getting old." She lives in Northern Wisconsin, an are with rampant Lyme's Disease because it is so wooded. Both her daughter & grandson who live in the same area were treated for over a year for Lyme's. She was not . I am livid that this vibrant woman is now just a shell because doctors dismissed her symptoms as "old age."
And you should be livid that her doctors were dismissive of her symptoms as being "old age". Neither pain nor cognitive issues are normal at any stage of life, including in geriatric patients.
But that doesn't mean that your mother has Lyme disease. My 82-year-old mother shouldn't be living alone any longer, and probably should be in a nursing home instead. Yes, she has chronic pain, but that's because she has osteoarthritis (and can't take the more effective pain meds), has a burnt-out case of an inflammatory form of arthritis and, separate from that, has cognitive problems that have just barely crossed the line into dementia. She has never, NEVER, been bitten by a tick.
Your mother's pain can be the result of any number of undiagnosed problems. There are many different causes and types of dementia. You can do something to help your mother, and that something may help her to return to being closer to the mother that you miss. You can make certain that she sees a good rheumatologist and that she sees a gerontologist who is not working at that nursing home.
GP doctors in general do not recognize any medical problem unless its obvious and something simple. Usually they send you to a specialist or they have their support office staff treat you. You are better off to pull up your medical concerns on MD.com to see what the real solutions to your problems might be.
No. You are not trained to interpret symptoms, test results, etc. But you can and should insist on being further assessed by specialists. If you go to a specialist in a given field and that doctor doesn't think that it's the right field for you, you'll be sent to someone in a more appropriate field for you. But diagnosing yourself is akin to pleading your own case in court, except that when you self-diagnose, you can end up in the morgue.
I have treated a number of "Lyme"disease cases the last number of years with some very good success rates. I have discovered that it is not caused by a germ, however, most of the time the symptoms are the result of a body that has been weakened mainly by a surgeon's scalpel.A surgeon's knife will create an inflammation that is trapped and will weaken the body.When I treat those surgical areas and reduce the inflammation, the patient's symptoms of "Lyme" disease go away and they improve physically.
Doctor, how many patients have you seen who have had surgery and DON'T display any symptoms of "chronic" Lyme disease? And how many patients have you seen to who do display symptoms of "chronic" Lyme disease but have never had surgery?
AKA, your control group consists of? Empirical proof needs studies that include control groups. It also needs multiple studies, constructed in the same manner, run in different places by different research teams, with different people in both groups of each study, and all of the studies being able to replicate the results of one another. Do you have that proof?
If you wait for double-blind studies, the US will never come up with the answers! There is another concept of testing that is called proving. If I have a number of cases of Lyme disease that I have cured, that proves I have done something to affect the case.
Even Louis Pasteur, who came up with the germ theory of disease, recanted on his deathbed and said, the germ is nothing, the terrain is all!
I am an active medical physician (40+ years practicing medicine) and it would be totally unethical for me to use patients in a blind study. People come to see me to get better and not be part of experimental test. If they want to be part of experimental test, they can sign-up someplace with some pharmaceutical research or something like that.
My job is to figure out what created the problem in the first place and then reverse it and get the patient better. I would match my results with "lyme"the disease with anyone out there. If I have to wait for the system to find an answer, then I would have to tell the patient that there is nothing that I can do because the system says that there is nothing that can be done at the present time. Also, the US ranks 49th in the world in healthcare and longevity according to the World Health Organization, so why should I wait for these so-called "experts" to come up with an answer before I treat any cases.
Albert Einstein said, "insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result". That's exactly what you're talking about!
Dr. B, inflammation from surgery resolves. The inflammation from surgery does not persist for years, trapped nor is there any evidence that this would induce say, autoimmunity which would cause persistent systemic inflammation in many cases. It sounds like you are saying that lyme, presumably chronic, would not be infectious in origin (note: I do not believe in chronic lyme).
Pasteur never said what you mentioned above. In fact, infectious disease denialists such as ones who proclaim that AIDS is not caused by HIV believe that Pasteur recanted his theory on his deathbed - which is a known fabrication. Curious doctor, do you wash your hands before you see patients?
I have been studying inflammation by viewing the live blood for the past 25 years. Just by watching an account in the size of the platelets can tell you how much inflammation there is. Platelets are the bodies first reaction against an injury which creates an inflammation and that starts up the healing process. A platelet count is very important and it's meaning is passed over by traditional allopathic medicine today.
I am a surgeon and my hands are always clean. I was a trauma surgeon in Vietnam from 1968 to 1969.
By the way, I do not believe that there is inherent in the forest that has an autoimmune disease and is supposedly allergic to itself. Do you believe that we have diseases that have been created because we are allergic to ourselves? That's what autoimmune means.
Yes I believe that autoimmunity exists and it some manifestations are horribly underdiagnosed (CIDP springs to mind for underdiagnosed autoimmunity). It seems so absurd that the tolerance to self would break down, but it does in some susceptible people. That is one theory of the so called chronic lyme - the infection itself has been eradicated but there potentially is molecular mimicry occurring, where now the immune system recognizes tissues as foreign, such as in the joints. Prolonged courses of antibiotics are useless in treating autoimmunity in the absence of infection, and have the potential to encourage development of abx-resistant bacteria not to mention the side effects of just a single course of abx. Autoimmunity of any type is a tricky disease to treat as you no doubt know.
I would be interested in sources for the platelet size and inflammatory status in the body; this is the first time I have heard of this.
read the book "Doctors Are More Harmful Than Germs".There is also a concept that was supported by several Nobel Prize winners called Homotoxicology. There are charts that have been developed explaining the above concept.
If you cut your arm for example, the first response body has is to bring in platelets to seal off the bleeding. Also, if you research it, you will find that platelets contain many proteins called cytokines which are major immune response molecules.
I meant to say in the above paragraph that I believe there is not a deer in the forest that suffers from an autoimmune disease or being allergic to itself.
I'm probably in need of my morning caffeine, but I don't get your deer comment. I am probably being too literal though. As a doctor, you must know that autoimmunity represent a real medical burden to many?
Autoimmune diseases are increasing dramatically in our society today. However, I do not believe we are allergic to ourselves and I believe that the medical system has created the term autoimmune because frankly, they have been total failures and do not know what they're doing. Traditional medicine in the US today has not found a cause or cure of one chronic disease in 100 years and therefore they are not experts!
Autoimmune means we are allergic to ourselves. There is no way I believe that! As I have said previously, I do not believe that there is a deer forest that is allergic to itself, because that's what autoimmune means.
I wish you the best and see if you can find a good craniosacral osteopath who can probably help. Also, look up the September issue of the Townsend newsletter and there is a letter to the editor that I wrote that explains my philosophy on "lyme" disease.
An allergy is when your immune system perceives something put into your body as foreign, that is not an infection. Pollen, penicillin, eggs, peanuts, etc etc may cause a release histamine in susceptible individuals.
Autoimmunity is when your immune system attacks its own tissues. Not the same as an allergy.
BTW, I don't follow the homeopathy practice. Water does not have memory and more diluted does not equal more potent. Homotoxicology has been debunked time and time again. I will look up the letter you wrote in Townsend as I am curious.
Who debunked Homotoxicology?if it was the American medical experts, then you know my feelings on those people. Homotoxicology was backed up by several Nobel Prize winners, Otto Warburg and Albert Szvent-Giorgi specifically.
If you keep on looking for the germ and trying to treat that, you will never get better
Dr. B, we are in agreement on the germ part for chronic lyme. The germ's been eradicated, it's the lingering response against self, probably d/t molecular mimicry, that causes the lingering sx. Fix that, fix the patient. Keep treating with rounds and rounds of abx, keep the patient sick.
First, this article reflects one side of a debate. Not really accurate or helpful. Medicine is a "practice" - doctors are not gods and patients MUST become experts as to what they physically feel. Any third party with an opinion on what you do with your body is an INTERLOPER - unwanted, thank you!
I have been misdiagnosed with too many illnesses to even list. I have had the best medical care available to man. The quiver of symptoms have made me familiar with many practices of medicine - an allergist, cardiologist, epidemiologist, rheumatologist, neurologist (actually 2), orthopedist, pallative care expert and thrown in for good measure, the team at Rusk NYU, who tested and found the 30% drop in vocabulary and simple memory/problem solving!
As a result of the above, all possible illnesses have been eliminated. That's the tactic I took. I am left with positive tests for lyme, babesia and bartonella. I have "herks", I suffer daily pain, nausea and the runs all day. As a last resort, I am on antibiotic therapy, daily IV. It is helping with some of my symptoms. MORE than any other doctor could do.
I AM SICK TO DEATH of this illness being debated! So the thousands of us getting this treatment are all nuts who "want" to be ill and live marginally on disability? We all want the kind of ridicule you suffer from idiots who say, your faking, lazy or crazy?
This is my 6th year of illness and only the 8th month of working treatment! I'll take the IV and ignore this article, thanks. I suggest anyone who thinks CHRONIC LYME doesn't exist, goes for a long walk in the woods, pet a couple of deers and gets this illness. Then write an article.
Till then, I'll see you in the waiting room..... or even better, interview someone from the other side of this debate.....
I have not had the extensive medical care as you have listed due to having a limited insurance, but I have seen doctor after doctor to treat the symptoms I am showing and to test for the possible illnesses I may have. Of course, nothing is working when it comes to making me better. Yes the medicine may take away some pain or cover my symptoms, but when those medicines are taken away, I am just as sick, if not more sick, as I was previously. I have been ill for 12 of my 20 years, and I can tell you it is not all in my head. The doctors know there is something wrong, but refuse to admit it is lyme, though they are unable to find any other cause. I was tested years ago and came back positive, but the doctor gave me under 2 months of antibiotics and sent me on my way. I have had the symptoms in the orders of the stages lyme is said to have, and I have a herx everytime I am put on an antibiotic for something like bronchitis. I refuse to believe that everything I am feeling or going through is a lie.
To those who agree with this article, you have no idea. Just because you're ill with one of the illnesses that lyme can look like doesn't mean you have the medical knowledge to state whether it is real or not. You are ignorant, and until you have more knowledge on the topic, or have gone through what those of us who suffer from lyme daily, then be respectful and shut your mouths. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but you need to learn when it is time to back off.
And to go along with what hope said, it is not like I don't go through a single day wishing that I wasn't sick. I'm a college student with a part time job who is too sick to make it to most of her classes because she can't get the rest or help she needs medical wise. Every day I wish that I could be a "normal" college student. I am in a constant fight to show my teachers and those around me that, even though I am struggling so much, I can still graduate college without having to take time off or take less classes a term. And yet, unlike most of you, I go through everyday with a smile on my face. It's really hard sometimes, but I do not want others to know that each push forward is killing me inside. I'm not going to give up with trying to fight this illness, and I'm not going to let any of you cynics get in my way.
rerae, what you've said simply makes you a walking advertisement for the desperate need for universal health insurance. That way, you can go to the doctor who you need to see (rheumatologist) who can do a far better job of finding your proper diagnosis, and then help you to manage it.
The number of meds tools for managing auto-immune illnesses are increasing by leaps and bounds, because they are the direct result of the research being done into the genetics of auto-immune problems. And meds are not the only management tools available to anyone.
Medical management tools are the first step. THe second is being able to cure, and the third and final is being able to prevent. That's where the research is going.
iInd a way to see a rheumatologist. Seeing one in a teaching hospital-based clinic is your best bet.
I have seen a few rheumatologists. They have checked me for many different things. You don't know my situation, or any of these others situations. Just because it has not been completely uncovered yet, doesn't mean lyme doesn't exist. You have your opinion as I have mine. Don't sit here and tell me what you believe is best for me when you don't even know me, or my case.
For those of you that hate allopathic doctors, please stop coming. I am not an egomaniac but bound by ethics to not sell you something I cannot support with current medical literature. Please stick to your snake oil salesmen, hopefully they at least make you feel better as I often cant as ethics keep me from telling you anything other than what current medical literature would support. Most folks keep going to the doctor until they hear what they want, or someone who justifies their dysfunction, or "listens" to them. I can do that but refuse to sacrificee my personal ethic to make a dollar. But please help yourself if that is who make you feel better.
I suspect that the "doubters" amongst the General Public and amongst the Doctors are NOT CONSIDERING the Immunology of the body when expressing their skepticism.
Once infected with some microorganisms, an Auto-Immune disease ensues...which will most likely last for the person's entire life and will require regular treatment in order to keep the disabling symptoms at bay.
I am NOT a Doctor...but I have had Auto-Immune disease for 25 years.(NOT Lyme Disease)I believe that I know a little bit about some of this.
It is naive and counter-productive to dismiss "chronic" Lyme Disease as non-existent. Ask ANY qualified Immunologist.
more than 90 percent of doctors know and believe chronic lyme disease exists they are just in fear of being brought the to medical board for treating it so they choose to ignore it.
the people on this thread who are trying to deny lyme need to learn how to read and then do some.
Weird. I just heard from a friend, today, who I found is being treated for chronic Lyme. However, reading this article would convince ME that I had it! Who isn't fatigued and in some pain somewhere? Could someone please be really specific about the symptoms? I know about fibro and CFS-WAY more than I want to know. And I've been bitten by lots of ticks. But I've never noticed a rash.
Are you in significant pain. Do you need pain meds or psychotropics to make it through the day? Do these meds not really work for you anyway?
Were you highly functional one day, and caught some kind of flu-like illness that never went away.
Can you work? Can you drive a car? If so, can you drive a car without feeling lost?
Do you have terrible insomnia that can last for many days no matter how tired you may be? Do you wake at 4 AM every night feeling very sick?
Do you ever feel like you are going to die, and this feeling lingers for days or weeks? I am not talking about a thought. A feeling.
Have you ever had panic attacks that last the whole day or several days? Have you ever been to the hospital with a heart rate of over 200 bpm that wouldn't come down without beta blockers (heart medication), anxiolytics, and pain medicine for angina? Have you ever shown up to a hospital with triage thinking you are having a heart attack? I have, at 24 years old.
Do you ever go partially functional for several days or weeks, and for the next week you can't get out of bed because of pain/discomfort?
Do you have significant chest pain all the time? I do. It's better than it used to be thank god. It would be nice if it goes away.
Do you have hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills, and tens of thousands of dollars of out of pocket expenses? Have you been to your primary care physician, neurologist, psychiatrist, opthamologist, rheumatologist, endocrinologist with no answers? I have.
Do you have mitochondrial dysfunction? Do you not convert oxygen to energy properly. I don't. My fitness profile is in the bottom 1% of the population, and I used to be a super athlete and mountain biked 30 miles a day in the Sierra Nevada mountains. Now I get winded walking up the stairs slowly.
I have both CFS and Chronic Lyme Disease, and yes, some doctors and researchers are finding that these two diseases may be linked (XMRV retrovirus). My CFS doctor at first thought that I really didn't have Lyme Disease and CFS. In fact, he told me he really didn't believe in Chronic Lyme Disease anymore (I am in TX).
I got a phone call back from the nurse saying that the doctor thinks I do in fact have Lyme Disease.
I think a majority of people with Chronic Lyme Disease may have the newly discovered CFS retrovirus (HIV is a retrovirus) as well. However, I think a number of infections can trigger CFS.
I am much better than I was, but unfortunately I am not well. I have to live with my parents now as I still can't drive a car or work. I gave my car to my older sister.
Now that being said, if you met me and I didn't tell you anything, you probably couldn't guess that I am sick. I can walk, talk, and look otherwise normal. I go out when I feel ok enough to do so, but in reality I am suffering and feeling symptoms all the time.
You obviously don't know anything about CFS, Fibro, or Lyme. There are many that are bed or wheelchair bound. You won't see the most serious cases, because those people can't leave their room for a number of reasons (neurological, sensitivity to any stimulation, severe pain, etc).
Why don't you just thank god that you have your health. Some of us are not so fortunate. I am 24, and these ARE NOT aches and pains of daily living. Step back and have compassion for others. You can't even compare yourself to others with these conditions, so please don't try.
I truly understand your maladies and the pain you endure everyday. I have utmost Empathy for you as you are so young & must live the rest of your life with such. I just now posted my history and am with you on those who are healthy to Thank God each day they are.
I'm beginning to see that the younger generation is more apt to help me open the heavy doors that doctor's use, which I do not understand. I had one young nurses aid who helped me with my scooter as I was at my Breast Specialist & it was sunny when I went in, but was storming when I came out. I tried to wait the storm out, but the pain was getting to severe & knew I had a 40 mile drive home. The wind was blowing my umbrella wrong side out.
This young lady told me to hold onto my umbrella & step back with my rollator. She was a very thin young lady; however, she didn't mess with the remote control. She just picked up my scooter and put it in the back of my van and took off down the hill to the employees parking lot. I was so upset I didn't see her name tag. There are lots of doctor's offices &a surgical center in the lower floor of this building. I would say she was in her young 20's.
It's my generation (the baby boomers) who just look at me & don't even try to help me open doors. I carry a small cane with a handle on it to try to open the doors; however, it's getting to the point where I call the office & tell them I'm at the door & to please send someone to open it.
Wish a healthy person could just spend one full day 'in our shoes' and I'm sure their thinking and their life would be changed for the betterment of those who are severely handicapped.
Will add you to my morning & evening Prayers as I've come to realize that Prayers are quite Mighty. God Bless you Kyle.
Kyle, sorry, I didn't mean to sound unfeeling. I was just expressing that the symptoms listed were very general. As a sufferer of severe chronic migraines I am not indifferent to pain and suffering. Without my preventive meds (2 anti convulsants) I would likely be in bed in a dark room every day. As it is I still have a migraine to some degree every day. I also have fibromyalgia, which means my whole body hurts every day. I can't take NSAIDS for fear of rebound headaches, which I have experienced-it's better just to stretch and do relaxation exercises for the pain. I also don't take narcotics due to being a recovering alcoholic. There are days when I can hardly move-like you, no one can see anything wrong with me, so there is no sympathy at all. Without meds I don't sleep at all, period. Since the mind can't go without sleep, I start to lose it after about 3 nights. I have had a positive test for narcolepsy some years ago, though the doctor questioned whether it was valid. I still sleep more than 12 hours-some days I'm only up for about 5 hours or so. I also have neurological problems-my neurologist thinks I have a neuropathy, though nothing has ever shown up. I gave up talking to doctors about all of this long ago-I'm doing well to have a doctor who believes fibromyalgia exists. Can't tell you how many docs have thought things were all in my head, even in the ER. Once I was denied not only treatment but also food and water for 48 hours in the hospital when I had a spinal headache from a spinal tap received in their ER. My own family doesn't believe I'm sick. So I'm sorry if I came across as not caring. I didn't mean to.
P.S. The last time I showed up at the hospital with a heart problem (PVC's) they just shoved me into the back of the ER and left me alone all night without even monitoring me. After 6 hours when I fell asleep they did an EKG which picked up nothing, then they sent me home. I discovered later that I do have an anomaly in my valve which causes the PVC's.
Just a few more additions. Kyle, I really do feel for you. Believe it or not I have seen a lot of people like you, as I was once team leader of a chronic pain/industrial rehab center. So I have seen extreme amounts of disability due to pain and fibromyalgia. No one discussed chronic lyme back then. I never thought I would wind up in their shoes! At least I do have a good bit of knowledge of how to self treat and make myself as functional as possible. Part of me is probably jealous that you have doctors that actually listen to you and take you seriously. I have to walk on eggshells around the docs I have b/c too often I've had docs who were fine turn on me and suddenly start offering Xanax for everything from fevers to coughs. That's when I know I have to find another doc. At that point they will never investigate anything or do any testing or anything b/c they've made up their minds that everything, and I mean everything is all in my head.
That seems to be a trend these days. My husband says his PA treats him that way, and he's never had a psychiatric problem or taken an antidepressant in his life! It seriously ticks me off! I know there's a connection between mind and body and all that, but EVERYTHING is not all in your head. I wonder if they do that b/c they're too lazy to do testing. I've just given up and pretty much keep it all to myself.
Thanks for your replies. Sorry that I misinterpreted your post. I thought you were just one of the common folks bashing people with these diseases/syndromes.
Sorry about that, and I definitely know what you mean about doctors using Xanax for everything.
When I ended up in the hospital after I got ill, I usually ended up on Ativan with a suggestion to see a psychiatrist. It didn't matter that my heart reached over 200 bpm, and stayed over 100 bpm while sedated to sleep in the ER. Most doctors really just don't care.
I'm lucky to have a team of doctors that listens to me without trying to pull a new psychiatric diagnosis out of their hat. Sure, I have anxiety, and it used to be terrible. It was the worst anxiety my doctor has seen in his career (and he was an older doctor). However, most doctors still don't understand that severe anxiety like I had was the consequence of a disease state, not because of my mind.
I went 15 years with all kinds of symptoms & visited doctor after doctor who told me it was all in my head. As a child from 10 until 20 yrs. of age,we went camping every weekend. Yes, tick bites galore. I've never had any Lyme tests completed. Those tests were unheard of in our backward State. However, I finally went to a Diagnostic Clinic in 1990 & was diagnosed with Severe Fibromyalgia.
I'm 56 years old & recv'd my SSD in 2006 with Judge awarding my disability back to Oct. 2004. Since then, I've had 7 surgeries on my spine (cervical and lumbar) due to crumbling spine & osteophytes (bone spurs) all over my spine. One in my cervical area pushed on a disk & caused the matter to be hanging over my other disks. A simple X-ray showed such. Thus one surgery was a Posterior Laminectomy of 4 disks & decompression of the cervical spine - worst surgery & pain of all my surgeries.
My dxs by my Neurosurgeon is Severe Degenerative Disk & Joint Disease, Severe Osteoarthritis & Arachnoiditis, Permanent Nerve Damage in Left Leg/Foot and 100% Disabled. He doesn't believe in Fibromyalgia; however he prescribed Lyrica for severe peripheral Neuropathy. When Lyrica hit the market it was only for Diabetic Neuropathy. Then advertised for the PN & now is advertised for Fibromyalgia relief.
Have a Spinal Cord Stimulator implanted because of Arachnoiditis, which in layman's term is a cobweb of nerve roots. Every year more nerves are being added to the cobweb. Now I am inoperable on my lumbar spine. I cannot walk without the use of a rollator (walker with large wheels,hand brakes, & seat) in the house or a scooter for use when away from home, which Medicare would not pay for either.
I'm unable to do any housecleaning including washing clothes as my hands will not allow me to remove the clothes from the washing machine. I can load our dishwasher, altho it takes me about 3 hrs. to do so & take clothes out of the dryer. Any type of tasks takes a long time to complete. Although at times my mind is sharp as a tack & other times I cannot remember squat. Short term memory is almost completely gone. I was an Accountant before being disabled & continue to pay our bills (never overdrawn our checking account) & complete tax returns for ourselves and my husband's family.
As my husband is a Long Haul Truck Driver I'm alone at least 5-6 days out of the week. Because of all the pain pills (including morphine) my Neurosurgeon & Pain Management Doctor rx'd over the 5 years ago, I'm just began seeing a Neurologist whose is running brain tests (No MRI due to Spinal Cord Stimulator) so they are Cat Scans, EMGS & brain monitoring for a week. I will know results this Wednesday. I want off these pain pills because it also crumbled my teeth in an 8 mth. period. Oral surgeon removed my all my teeth in 2 surgeries. Before I could get my impressions made for my dentures, I was found to have bone spurs all across my upper and lower gum line. Thus, another surgery in Sept. 3 months of anesthesia takes a toll on a normal person, much less one whose immune system is so suppressed.
We live in a very small town (pop. 2,401) and is a long way to see doctors in a major city. The day before I need to drive to see my doctors, I quit taking all my meds. I end up going 1 1/2 days w/o them & yes the withdrawal symptoms occur, like sweating, nausea, etc. Van is equipped with a remote control lift to easily remove my scooter. Medicare would only pay for a regular wheel chair.
Because of the severe osteoarthritis my hands & feet (with 3 toes on left foot that will not move)look like a person with rhuematoid Arthritis. I'm right handed & it is the worse. So manual wheelchair is of no use to me. I wear Depends (going thru 4-7 a day) because I've lost bladder control and the Urologist I saw wanted to put a TVT sling in Dec. 2008. I just happened to see a FDA Warning on msnbc.com on Oct. 19,2008 warning the new slings for bladder & hernia operations was made with a petroleum based product causing them to dry up & move into other organs in your body & causing severe pain & many removal surgeries, as once dried up..not easy to find. I called to set up appt. at end of 10/08 & was told I could get appt. 2 days before surgery. Cancelled everything and requested records.
My husband is trying to look for a job within a 75 mile radius of our home; however, as all know jobs are hard to come by. He is 54(at age 50 had 5 bypass surgery & in less than 4 mths. needed a pacemaker implanted) & truck driving is the only job he's held besides being a truck dispatcher for 7 1/2 yrs.
So I don't care what you write, Lyme Disease is real and as you get older the disease causes all kinds of other maladies. I'm a Living Example of what it can cause. You can debate all my issues (which will just be consonants & vowels to me) all you want; however, until you 'walk in my shoes' you don't know the facts.
IMPORTANT FACTS: This article below documents the available evidence supporting both the existence of Chronic Lyme Disease, as well as the persistence of the infection despite antibiotic therapy. The abstracts are available on U.S. Government's Public Medical Database [pubmed.gov].
The Case For Chronic Infection: Evidential persistence of Borrelia species post antibiotic exposure in vivo and in vitro.
Reuter's article is misleading, suggesting that only a "small" group of doctors in Connecticut recognize the disease, but the reality is that physicians around the world are quietly treating and diagnosing Chronic Lyme Disease, including in many countries: Germany, Brazil, UK, Mexico and every state in the United States. There are thousands of physicians treating this infection, but this survey was only performed in Connecticut.
Few doctors in Connecticut would dare treat or recognize Chronic Lyme Disease unless they want to end up like Charles Ray Jones. Many physicians I've spoken to cite his trial as a primary reason that they avoid going public about their involvement, or getting involved at all with this controversial condition. Even with a new law in place to protect physicians, they know as well as I do that there are other ways to skin a physician who decides to treat outside the guidelines of the IDSA. Dr. Jones was the perfect example. They didn't nail him to the cross because he used long term antibiotics. They did it claiming he prescribed and diagnosed a patient by telephone. Physicians I've spoken to tell me "They don't have to take away my license because I treat Lyme Disease long term, they can accuse me of something totally unrelated and still achieve the same goal of stripping me of my ability to treat patients."
Hard to argue with those facts, am I right?
Now the reality is, the evidence is abundant suggesting the infection dose persist. That's the truth. You can use "facts" to obscure the truth, and you can report doctors to state medical boards for treating this condition, but this epidemic is spreading whether you wish to recognize that or not.
Let's look at a few quotes from studies published in well respected peer-reviewed journals that support my statements regarding persistence.
"We conclude that the treatment of Borrelia burgdorferi (Lyme Disease) with appropriate antibiotics for even more than 3 months may not always eradicate the spirochete." - Ann Med. 1999 Jun; 3,3:225-32.
"The Lyme disease spirochete, can be recovered long after initial infection, even from antibiotic-treated patients, indicating that it resists eradication by host defense mechanisms and antibiotics".- 1:20 J Infect Dis. 1992 Aug;166,2:440-4
This new method for culturing B. burgdorferi from patients with chronic Lyme disease certainly defines the nature of the illness and establishes that it is of chronic infectious etiology." - Infection. 1998 Nov-Dec; 26,6:364-7
"These data demonstrate that Lyme neuroborreliosis is a persistent infection."- Ann Neurol. 2001 Sep;50,3, :330-8
"In one of the six analysed brain tissue specimens [from a patient that received more than six months of antibiotic treatment prior to death, including two 3-week courses of IV ceftriaxone], B. burgdorferi DNA was detected by PCR." - Brain. 1996 Dec;119, Pt 6:2143-54
"Two hundred seventy-seven patients with chronic Lyme disease were treated with tetracycline for 1 to 11 months, These results support the use of longer courses of treatment in the management of patients with chronic Lyme disease." - Clin Infect Dis. 1997 Jul;25 Suppl 1:S52-6.
I have more than 100 studies just like these above. They can't all be wrong, now can they?
A lot of diseases and conditions don't exist until the drug companies create a very expensive pill or vaccine for it. Then the doctors are rushing to tell you that you have this condition. The problem with chronic lyme disease is that the drug companies have not found a pill for it yet, once they do, it will be recognized and treated, and then everyone will have the disease. Doctors and drug companies don't make money off people that are healthy.
I was treated for over 3 years with "chronic lyme" including by one to the top "Lyme" docs in Conn. After being blasted and sickened by antibiotics without improvement I looked elsewhere. Thank you Ritchie Shoemaker in Maryland for finding my house and body was full of toxic mold. He used just a bit more science than just treating me symptomatically to diagnosis me with mold illness. During my time in the "Lyme" community I found many people who were chronically ill. I felt many of these people where married to their disease. I refused to be married to my illness and sought out help in other areas which led me to Shoemaker. My house is now clean and my body while still recovering is much better.
RIGHT ON! HARVEY! My son and I were full of mold, mercury & other additives from vaccines. etc. That made us horrifically sick in addition to the poisons from Lyme & co-infections!
We were detoxed via www.AdvancedCellTraining.com -ACT, which worked amazingly~And have had long term involvement in the process. Even to address the emotional trauma caused by the lack of help as well as personal struggles!
After being poisoned by the heparin from China, which killed thousands, I could no longer try antibiotics, they were now poison. My son, too, could only take so much of the antibiotics before he had an adverse reaction!
The ionic foot bath does great...you actually see the flakes of heavy metal.
Chronic Lyme disease is the newest pidgeon hole for patients who used to "have" fibromyalgia, and that "disease" was the follow up to chronic fatigue syndrome. Most of these people are not ill, they just complain. There is no objective measurable test for any of these so called diseases/syndromes. You must have a diagnosis to get insurance to pay for the treatment, otherwise you are NOT ill.
Agree. If all the screening tests for Lyme are negative...then your achiness/headaches/exhaustion and whatever else are caused by something else.
The issue IS the testing. Standard Lyme disease testing is only 65% accurate; this standard of testing would not be accepted for any other ailment. Imagine a doctor giving you a diagnosis of cancer, for example, based on a test that's 65% accurate. And just for the record, I have never experienced chronic lyme disease myself, or any of the other "complainer" diseases.
I can be reached for comment and I believe I have Lyme disease that periodically flares. I've read the opinion on both side of the debate and the opposition offers nothing to account for my recurring symptoms.
The latest, and worst, is an extremely painful cyst in my knee. These cysts have been proven to be caused by and harbor Lyme spirochetes. Despite 5 month living with constant pain and a reduction in mobility that prevents me from working--my job requires agility at the very least--I cannot find a doctor to treat the cyst.
Kris you're giving the ELISA test too much accuracy. According to the American College of Pathologists, it is accurate merely 45% of the time.
I recently tested double positive for lyme on the standard Elisa and Western Blot tests and the CD 57 and have been chronically ill for over 15 years. What I have found is that doctors are now agreeing that fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue are multiple infection syndrome and in addition to a person possibly having lyme bacteria they most often have an overload of several coexisting infections such as Epstein Barr and others. As far as this not being real, I can assure you I would do ANYTHING to get better and ride my horses and be active with my kids again!
As for testing, it is true that adrenal and thyroid issues accompany multiple infection syndrome and are testable, but another good test is the tilt table test. Many doctors are finding their fibromyalgia patients will have quite a significant drop in blood pressure upon rising. (Mine drops 20 pts. currently.) Furthermore, one can also easily examine blood under a dark field microscope and see the lyme spirochetes.
Lastly, multiple infection syndrome including lyme disease also can cause mitochondrial (the batteries of the cells) failure issues which can account for the inability to have quality energy and the need to physically recharge after any exertion.
For those who are ill, DO NOT GIVE UP and do not let anyone tell you that this is in your head (as some of my doctors did initially)! It sucks that our medical system is so political and money oriented and not focused on quality whole person care. Nevertheless, there truly are millions of people suffering from an overload of infections (and toxins) who can recover as long as they receive the right care and support! One might also want to google Transfer Factors (the good stuff from egg yolk, colostrom, and immune supporting nutrients) as well as they have been showing significant results for years in helping chronically ill people recover their energy and function. I WISH GOOD HEALTH TO YOU ALL! Life is too short to suffer through it!
You have obviously never experienced chronic fatigue. How can you say that it doesn't exist if you have never experienced it?
Hmmm..... I wonder how my nephew feels about all the problems he's had for the past 10 years being just a figment of his imagination. He used to be very active, doing triathlons, road races, etc. Now he struggles at less than half the energy he had, not to mention the physical problems, headaches, etc. But, I guess it is good to know that all he has to do is think positive and it will go away.
Has he been to a rheumatologist yet? I was sick for 12 years til I got a diagnosis of psoriatic arthritis.
It is my understanding that Lyme disease can cause arthritic changes.
Although it is moving pain, without any deformation.
Independent Thought, that doesn't rule out some of the more than 100 different types of arthritis.
I have three types, and each of them affect just about every part of my body. But they don't affect every part of my body all the time. Some days, and for that matter, some hours, one joint, one body part, may be causing me a lot of pain. Sometimes it's another joint or another part. Sometimes it's all over, and sometimes everything is a bit sore but nothing is painful.
This is what happens when you have even one type of arthritis. Yes, that includes having "only" osteoarthritis, but in more than one joint. And if even one of your types of arthritis is inflammatory, then it can take anywhere from weeks (aggressive rheumatoid arthritis) to years, even at times, decades (ie, psoriatic arthritis), for the damage to show up on x-rays.
Been there, done that, and I'd like to throw out the #$)(#*$ T-shirt.
The Road Back Foundation - http://www.roadback.org/
To be replaced, Kyle by extreme candida infections that have the same set of symptoms as does "chronic" Lyme disease.
I'm no fan of the pharmaceutical industry, but some antibiotics really help.
What works best for me is Colloidal Silver. No side effects, kills candida infections, and works better in general than any antibiotic for me for "chronic" Lyme Disease and "CFS".
I was on a powerful IV antibiotic called Rocephin, and I hate to say it, but I think a good Colloidal Silver is more effective.
But that being said, there are pharmaceuticals to treat and prevent yeast infections. Diflucan and Nystatin to name a couple.
So what's the proper solution? Inject steroids for the rest of their life for all these "auto-immune" diseases? Sure your body may have developed antibodies against your own cells, but how does that prove there isn't an underlying infectious agent at the root cause?
There's a lot we don't know, and more that we don't want to acknowledge.
So instead of using antibiotics for a potential disease remission, we should compromise our immune system with steroids?
I guess we can't win either way, can we?
Remicade has been my saving grace, but I am one of the lucky ones who have insurance. It bothers me to know there are people who have that kind of pain and can't get this medicine.
I was diagnosed as having fibromyalgia, although it is just a name for a collection of symptoms, I was instructed to take anti-inflammatory, anti-anxiety and anti-depressants as treatment. Goodness. Didn't fill the scripts. I moved to alternative care at that point in time. I did test positive on the Lymes test CD 57, which is covered by insurance, via an MD who focus's on finding the cause not treating symptoms. I used glutathione to detox, supported my adrenals and thryoid, with great results.
Anyone who has fatigue, speech issues, brain fog, aching, headaches, etc. needs to ensure their adrenals are well (possibly needing better sleep, supplements, hormone therapy and reduction of stressers), and more importantly thyroid function testing. Dr. Lowe (google his work) has done extensive work with fibro, chronic fatigue, and has found hypothryoid (BTW: standard normal lab ranges are too broad) as often the underlying issue. Once I got on the correct dosage of armour thyroid(with both T3 and T4), and a TSH range close to 1.5, all my issues went away.
Was it only adrenal and thyroid issues or chronic lymes? Maybe the lymes created the adrenals and thyroid issue, or not? Personally, I really don't care, now that I feel great.
those who deny chronic lyme disease have never experienced chronic lyme disease
TRUE! Bless you Lexiwords2. It is a tough situation, especially depending on the infection load.
Those who claim to have chronic Lyme diseae have doctors who are too lazy to find the real reason for their symptoms.
If you really want to feel well again, CHANGE DOCTORS!
I did.
I found a doctor who doesn't believe he is God and actually listens to his patients. The only thing that accounts for my constellation of symptoms is Lyme disease. I'm on my third course of antibiotics in 5 months and, aside from my knee, I'm starting to feel improvement.
The lazy docs are the ones who won't listen to their patients and want an easy, tidy quick fix.
jkatzw, Lyme disease is NOT the only illness that accounts for those symptoms. That's my point. The list of all of the possible symptoms of "chronic" Lyme disease mirrors the lists of some other problems, including some of the less-well known types of arthritis.
The lazy doctors are the ones who listen to their patients and don't want to understand that the patient has self-diagnosed by searching the internet for a name of something that seems to fit their symptoms. I'm not saying that you necessarily did that, but did you have in mind that you had a particular problem when you first saw that doctor? Even that can influence the diagnosis of a lazy doctor because it influences what you say to that doctor. t points that doctor in the direction of your untrained opinion.
EXACTLY!!!!!
My husband received a positive lyme diagonosis 4 years ago. He had a rash and a high fever. After the recommended treatment we were told he was cured, but no tests were run to prove this. Since then he developed afib (irregular heartbeat) which is being treated. He has also gone through 6 weeks of physical therapy on his shoulder. The pain can come and go and the therapy was not successful. His hips, knees, and feet have also become almost crippling on certain days. The drugs that his doctor's prescribed have not appeared to work, and through all of the doctor visits we had asked if lymes could be a factor and NO one would re-test him. Last month we went to a llmd (lyme literate, medical doctor) who finally retested him, and yes he has active lymes! It is difficult not to resent the attitude of the traditional medical community, including the author of this article, with what our experience has been.
And a rheumatologist said what?
There is such a thing as infective arthritis, and there is such as thing as reactive arthritis. Both, if not properly treated, will continue to cause pain.
So again, what did his rheumatologist have to say??
Rediagnosed and Ind Thought, I hope you have both found at least pallative measures. Gentle massage also helps and if you're not allergic I'd try arnica and or sweet birch essential oils added to the massage oil. See an aromatherapist for a good massage mixture of not more than 30 drops total essential oil per ounce of carrier oil ( I have much experience and education in this). Use sparingly and test for allergies first.
Bless you both
What poor journalism. Did you interview anyone on the other side of this debate?
I had Lyme disease when I was 14. I was on a Boy Scout camping trip about 20 miles from Lyme, CT, and found a few ticks of various types crawling on me (but never noticed any feeding) during the course of the trip. I developed a rash soon after the trip, which evolved into a classic bullseye rash over the next day or two, then I got two or three more elsewhere on my body. The bullseye rash is the single most reliable symptom used to diagnose Lyme. My pediatric doctor didn't believe it was Lyme, but my mom made him give me doxycycline for it, which I took for 9 days. The rash went away, though I did develop a fever.
Now I'm 33. I've had issues with fatigue, depression, persistent headache, and cognitive function ("brain fog" would be an appropriate description) since I was an adolescent (soon after contracting Lyme). These issues developed slowly over time, and often would go through cycles of getting worse & better. Last year they finally got bad enough (mostly the fatigue and cognitive issues) where I realized that I was having trouble even doing basic tasks at work, and never had the energy to go to the gym any more. I suspected Lyme and sought treatment for it. I found an LLMD to test and treat me for Lyme. I had numerous tests done (iGeneX Lyme & coinfection blood tests, CD-57 NK, and others). The Lyme tests repeatedly showed a few weak or indeterminate positives on bands specific for Lyme, and a positive on the common 41 kPa band). The CD-57 showed rather low counts (98 once, then 64 the second time) of NK cells. I had *no* test results (past or present) that were positive for Lyme.
Based on these results, my history, and my clinical symptoms, my LLMD treated me for Lyme disease with several antibiotics over the course of 11 months. Zithromax, Metronidazole, Doxycycline, Penicillin-G, Rifampin, Mepron, and Alinia. I was on three or more of these simultaneously for at least six months, and on five for the final few months. I tracked my symptoms carefully, several times per day for the entire period. I would occasionally show significant improvement for up to a few days, but overall, I did not get any better, and (if anything) felt worse.
I went for an expensive second opinion evaluation at Columbia Medical Center in May, 2010. Based on their evaluation, and the fact that I hadn't improved after 11 months of antibiotics, they strongly suggested that I stop the antibiotics and that I probably didn't have Lyme. Shortly before this, one of my other doctors had the idea to check me for food allergies and gluten sensitivity. My results showed broad spectrum food allergies (dairy, soy, eggs, nuts, beef, and others), as well as several indicators for gluten sensitivity. I can't be sure if the allergies were caused/triggered by the antibiotics (see "Leaky Gut"), or if they were there from before, and possibly the root cause. I wish I'd been tested for these before the antibiotics. Apparently food allergies and gluten sensitivity can cause the same symptoms I've been having.
I've since seen other doctors (an endocrinologist to check my thyroid function, and an infectious disease specialist to review my other results). Neither returned any significant results (I have no diseases and my thyroid function is fine), and they both thought I has been improperly treated with antibiotics. I'm still seeking a root cause, but I'm currently focusing on maintaining an allergen-free, low-sugar diet, and repairing the damage to my GI system done by the antibiotics.
YMMV of course, but to anyone who thinks they might have "chronic Lyme", I'd strongly advise them to eliminate all other likely causes before considering treatment for it. Once you start treating chronic Lyme, it's very difficult to figure out when to stop. They tell you it could take months or years to get better. Months or years of antibiotics will do great harm to your body, and it's difficult to understand exactly what that means until you've done it. Plus, what happens when you've taken months or years of antibiotics, and you still haven't improved significantly? When do you stop?
Watch out for chronic Lyme diagnosis/treatment. I'm not saying it doesn't exist (even though this article strongly implies that), but it's easy to go down that road and waste a ton of time and money treating something you don't have, based solely on vague symptoms and best guesses. Not only this, you're *not* treating what you really might have wrong with you during that whole time, and you're also doing great harm to your body.
PS - Dr. Fallon at Columbia Medical Center told me that he has experimental evidence that the CD-57 NK test (commonly used to support a Lyme diagnosis) is completely useless. Between a healthy control group and a carefully selected Lyme-positive group, his research team found no significant difference in CD-57 results. Furthermore, they found that the CD-57 results were highly variable, often changing significantly even from hour to hour. They are in the process of publishing these results and conclusions, if they haven't already.
Pseudothink, these are the results that you get when you have an open mind about something as controversial as "chronic" Lyme disease. Good for you.
The tests for Lyme disease don't test for the presence of the bug but for the presence of the antibodies that a person who has been exposed to the bug has developed. That's all that they can do. They can't even tell if those antibodies developed in the last week or more than decade ago.
Here's an example of the equivalent to that test. Rubella is known as a "childhood disease" but if you happen to contract it while you're pregnant, it can do serious harm to the fetus. But, there is a vaccine against it. Your doctor can tell if you need this vaccine by running a blood test that checks for antibodies to rubella. Those antibodies can have developed at any time in the past. But you don't show the antibodies, and you're a woman of child-bearing age, the vaccine is advisable. It's the same concept, and it measures only for the presence of an antibody. It can't tell you how long that antibody has been present.
I don't see a reference in your post to a rheumatologist. So, arrange to see one, because there are types of arthritis that can explain your lingering symptoms. And if you have seen one, get a second opinion. It's your right.
Thanks rpearlston! I've heard the suggestion to see a rheumatologist before, but given that I've run out of things to investigate for the moment, I'm more interested now. I'm just worried that I'd show up for the appointment, explain my symptoms (fatigue, cognitive difficulty, headache, tinnitus), and the doctor would just ask me why I thought he could help me with them. I don't have an answer for that, nor any clue about what tests he might do that would help. I don't have significant joint pain or joint-related problems that I'm aware of, but I suspect there is more to rheumatology than that? Perhaps it's just the result of inflammation caused by some sort of autoimmune problem?
Pseudothink, as an arthritis patient myself, I can guarantee you that those symptoms are common to many types of arthritis.
Yes, there is more to rheumatology than just explaining joint and joint-related pain. There are more than 100 different types of arthritis, and most of them have little to nothing to do with joint pain. Most, in fact, are auto-immune disorders, and they seem to need an environmental "trigger" of some sort. For you, that may well have been Lyme disease.
Do you best to ensure that the rheumatologist that you see is working in a rheumatology clinic at a teaching hospital. These doctors are clincian/researchers, and are constantly moving that "cutting edge" forwards.
Remember that you don't need a clue as to which tests any doctor will run. Your role as a patient is to be as honest as you can be with your personal and family histories, with your reactions to the physical exam, and with your answers to the questions that any doctor will then pose. Based on all of that, a doctor will decide which tests, both imaging and lab, should be run in order to assist in finding your diagnosis. And that can take a long time. We see that process in a very, very condensed version on the show "House", but it can take years. And everything that gets ruled out is actually a step forward simply because the diagnosis of less-well known problem is about ruling out the more common of the potential explanations. Doctors, after all, are trained to think horses, not zebras, when they hear hoof beats.
http://www.roadback.org/
Let me summarize that article in a few short words.
There is a very small number of doctors who are too lazy to look for any other health challenges.
That's it. That the article summarized in 18 words, one sentence.
The thing is that there are lots of health challenges with lists of symptoms that mirror the list of "chronic" Lyme disease symptoms. Being able to say, "yes, I have every one of those symptoms" or even , "yes, I have some of these symptoms" does not make the diagnosis "chronic" Lyme disease. Do your jobs, doctors, because as things stand now, the few of you who can't be bothered to do so have also forgotten about that part of the Hypocratic oath that says "first do no harm".
And to jklaser, FM patients are NOT chronic whiners. In fact, there are tests that prove this diagnosis. But a functional MRI is extremely expensive and not available in most places, and a lumbar puncture (spinal tap) is incredibly painful.
From reading all your comments and eyeballing the article, I would say a portion of you have got "the Worm". Toxocariasis.
However nobody mentioned scrotum swelling or blow-outs nor breathing trouble and coughing fits. With a good sized infestation (millions) sinuses are first , lungs are second and reproductive gear is third on where they affect/effect (attack), depending on how they entered you. Listlessness , fatigue, brainFog, depression, milky film on an eye or eyes, anger at Doctors....are all symptoms. If you regularily wake up semiNauseous or have hour(s) long coughing bouts in the middle of the night, if your inner ear is itching alot and your head aches daily, if your teeth are periodically sore and when removed the gum is reluctant to heal, I would recommend another professional exam.
If that option is no longer open (you are broke) ......Dip a cotton swab in 70% alcohol and clean out one (both) of your ears, look at the swab under a good light w/a jewelers loop and if you see any tiny blue or red or brown or green or translucent threads..............get a name brand inhaler and a bottle of "Clarkia" parasite cleanse. The difference between "the Worms" and fiber is that you can pull the creatures apart w/your fingers while fibers you cannot.
If you are male and are infested be prepared for a testicular swelling and blow-out. Ladies , I-m not so sure about. Hope this info helps one/some of you, I wish I'd-a got it 12 years ago.
I am convinced my mother-in-law has end stage Lyme's Disease. She now lives in dementia care facility with next to none short term memory. For many years she has had joint pain that was dismissed as "You've got to expect that. You're getting old." She lives in Northern Wisconsin, an are with rampant Lyme's Disease because it is so wooded. Both her daughter & grandson who live in the same area were treated for over a year for Lyme's. She was not . I am livid that this vibrant woman is now just a shell because doctors dismissed her symptoms as "old age."
And you should be livid that her doctors were dismissive of her symptoms as being "old age". Neither pain nor cognitive issues are normal at any stage of life, including in geriatric patients.
But that doesn't mean that your mother has Lyme disease. My 82-year-old mother shouldn't be living alone any longer, and probably should be in a nursing home instead. Yes, she has chronic pain, but that's because she has osteoarthritis (and can't take the more effective pain meds), has a burnt-out case of an inflammatory form of arthritis and, separate from that, has cognitive problems that have just barely crossed the line into dementia. She has never, NEVER, been bitten by a tick.
Your mother's pain can be the result of any number of undiagnosed problems. There are many different causes and types of dementia. You can do something to help your mother, and that something may help her to return to being closer to the mother that you miss. You can make certain that she sees a good rheumatologist and that she sees a gerontologist who is not working at that nursing home.
GP doctors in general do not recognize any medical problem unless its obvious and something simple. Usually they send you to a specialist or they have their support office staff treat you. You are better off to pull up your medical concerns on MD.com to see what the real solutions to your problems might be.
No. You are not trained to interpret symptoms, test results, etc. But you can and should insist on being further assessed by specialists. If you go to a specialist in a given field and that doctor doesn't think that it's the right field for you, you'll be sent to someone in a more appropriate field for you. But diagnosing yourself is akin to pleading your own case in court, except that when you self-diagnose, you can end up in the morgue.
I have treated a number of "Lyme"disease cases the last number of years with some very good success rates. I have discovered that it is not caused by a germ, however, most of the time the symptoms are the result of a body that has been weakened mainly by a surgeon's scalpel.A surgeon's knife will create an inflammation that is trapped and will weaken the body.When I treat those surgical areas and reduce the inflammation, the patient's symptoms of "Lyme" disease go away and they improve physically.
Doctor, how many patients have you seen who have had surgery and DON'T display any symptoms of "chronic" Lyme disease? And how many patients have you seen to who do display symptoms of "chronic" Lyme disease but have never had surgery?
AKA, your control group consists of? Empirical proof needs studies that include control groups. It also needs multiple studies, constructed in the same manner, run in different places by different research teams, with different people in both groups of each study, and all of the studies being able to replicate the results of one another. Do you have that proof?
If you wait for double-blind studies, the US will never come up with the answers! There is another concept of testing that is called proving. If I have a number of cases of Lyme disease that I have cured, that proves I have done something to affect the case.
Even Louis Pasteur, who came up with the germ theory of disease, recanted on his deathbed and said, the germ is nothing, the terrain is all!
I am an active medical physician (40+ years practicing medicine) and it would be totally unethical for me to use patients in a blind study. People come to see me to get better and not be part of experimental test. If they want to be part of experimental test, they can sign-up someplace with some pharmaceutical research or something like that.
My job is to figure out what created the problem in the first place and then reverse it and get the patient better. I would match my results with "lyme"the disease with anyone out there. If I have to wait for the system to find an answer, then I would have to tell the patient that there is nothing that I can do because the system says that there is nothing that can be done at the present time. Also, the US ranks 49th in the world in healthcare and longevity according to the World Health Organization, so why should I wait for these so-called "experts" to come up with an answer before I treat any cases.
Albert Einstein said, "insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result". That's exactly what you're talking about!
Dr. B, inflammation from surgery resolves. The inflammation from surgery does not persist for years, trapped nor is there any evidence that this would induce say, autoimmunity which would cause persistent systemic inflammation in many cases. It sounds like you are saying that lyme, presumably chronic, would not be infectious in origin (note: I do not believe in chronic lyme).
Pasteur never said what you mentioned above. In fact, infectious disease denialists such as ones who proclaim that AIDS is not caused by HIV believe that Pasteur recanted his theory on his deathbed - which is a known fabrication. Curious doctor, do you wash your hands before you see patients?
I have been studying inflammation by viewing the live blood for the past 25 years. Just by watching an account in the size of the platelets can tell you how much inflammation there is. Platelets are the bodies first reaction against an injury which creates an inflammation and that starts up the healing process. A platelet count is very important and it's meaning is passed over by traditional allopathic medicine today.
I am a surgeon and my hands are always clean. I was a trauma surgeon in Vietnam from 1968 to 1969.
By the way, I do not believe that there is inherent in the forest that has an autoimmune disease and is supposedly allergic to itself. Do you believe that we have diseases that have been created because we are allergic to ourselves? That's what autoimmune means.
Yes I believe that autoimmunity exists and it some manifestations are horribly underdiagnosed (CIDP springs to mind for underdiagnosed autoimmunity). It seems so absurd that the tolerance to self would break down, but it does in some susceptible people. That is one theory of the so called chronic lyme - the infection itself has been eradicated but there potentially is molecular mimicry occurring, where now the immune system recognizes tissues as foreign, such as in the joints. Prolonged courses of antibiotics are useless in treating autoimmunity in the absence of infection, and have the potential to encourage development of abx-resistant bacteria not to mention the side effects of just a single course of abx. Autoimmunity of any type is a tricky disease to treat as you no doubt know.
I would be interested in sources for the platelet size and inflammatory status in the body; this is the first time I have heard of this.
read the book "Doctors Are More Harmful Than Germs".There is also a concept that was supported by several Nobel Prize winners called Homotoxicology. There are charts that have been developed explaining the above concept.
If you cut your arm for example, the first response body has is to bring in platelets to seal off the bleeding. Also, if you research it, you will find that platelets contain many proteins called cytokines which are major immune response molecules.
I meant to say in the above paragraph that I believe there is not a deer in the forest that suffers from an autoimmune disease or being allergic to itself.
I'm probably in need of my morning caffeine, but I don't get your deer comment. I am probably being too literal though. As a doctor, you must know that autoimmunity represent a real medical burden to many?
Autoimmune diseases are increasing dramatically in our society today. However, I do not believe we are allergic to ourselves and I believe that the medical system has created the term autoimmune because frankly, they have been total failures and do not know what they're doing. Traditional medicine in the US today has not found a cause or cure of one chronic disease in 100 years and therefore they are not experts!
Autoimmune means we are allergic to ourselves. There is no way I believe that! As I have said previously, I do not believe that there is a deer forest that is allergic to itself, because that's what autoimmune means.
I wish you the best and see if you can find a good craniosacral osteopath who can probably help. Also, look up the September issue of the Townsend newsletter and there is a letter to the editor that I wrote that explains my philosophy on "lyme" disease.
An allergy is when your immune system perceives something put into your body as foreign, that is not an infection. Pollen, penicillin, eggs, peanuts, etc etc may cause a release histamine in susceptible individuals.
Autoimmunity is when your immune system attacks its own tissues. Not the same as an allergy.
BTW, I don't follow the homeopathy practice. Water does not have memory and more diluted does not equal more potent. Homotoxicology has been debunked time and time again. I will look up the letter you wrote in Townsend as I am curious.
Who debunked Homotoxicology?if it was the American medical experts, then you know my feelings on those people. Homotoxicology was backed up by several Nobel Prize winners, Otto Warburg and Albert Szvent-Giorgi specifically.
If you keep on looking for the germ and trying to treat that, you will never get better
Dr. B, we are in agreement on the germ part for chronic lyme. The germ's been eradicated, it's the lingering response against self, probably d/t molecular mimicry, that causes the lingering sx. Fix that, fix the patient. Keep treating with rounds and rounds of abx, keep the patient sick.
First, this article reflects one side of a debate. Not really accurate or helpful. Medicine is a "practice" - doctors are not gods and patients MUST become experts as to what they physically feel. Any third party with an opinion on what you do with your body is an INTERLOPER - unwanted, thank you!
I have been misdiagnosed with too many illnesses to even list. I have had the best medical care available to man. The quiver of symptoms have made me familiar with many practices of medicine - an allergist, cardiologist, epidemiologist, rheumatologist, neurologist (actually 2), orthopedist, pallative care expert and thrown in for good measure, the team at Rusk NYU, who tested and found the 30% drop in vocabulary and simple memory/problem solving!
As a result of the above, all possible illnesses have been eliminated. That's the tactic I took. I am left with positive tests for lyme, babesia and bartonella. I have "herks", I suffer daily pain, nausea and the runs all day. As a last resort, I am on antibiotic therapy, daily IV. It is helping with some of my symptoms. MORE than any other doctor could do.
I AM SICK TO DEATH of this illness being debated! So the thousands of us getting this treatment are all nuts who "want" to be ill and live marginally on disability? We all want the kind of ridicule you suffer from idiots who say, your faking, lazy or crazy?
This is my 6th year of illness and only the 8th month of working treatment! I'll take the IV and ignore this article, thanks. I suggest anyone who thinks CHRONIC LYME doesn't exist, goes for a long walk in the woods, pet a couple of deers and gets this illness. Then write an article.
Till then, I'll see you in the waiting room..... or even better, interview someone from the other side of this debate.....
Well stated.
I have not had the extensive medical care as you have listed due to having a limited insurance, but I have seen doctor after doctor to treat the symptoms I am showing and to test for the possible illnesses I may have. Of course, nothing is working when it comes to making me better. Yes the medicine may take away some pain or cover my symptoms, but when those medicines are taken away, I am just as sick, if not more sick, as I was previously. I have been ill for 12 of my 20 years, and I can tell you it is not all in my head. The doctors know there is something wrong, but refuse to admit it is lyme, though they are unable to find any other cause. I was tested years ago and came back positive, but the doctor gave me under 2 months of antibiotics and sent me on my way. I have had the symptoms in the orders of the stages lyme is said to have, and I have a herx everytime I am put on an antibiotic for something like bronchitis. I refuse to believe that everything I am feeling or going through is a lie.
To those who agree with this article, you have no idea. Just because you're ill with one of the illnesses that lyme can look like doesn't mean you have the medical knowledge to state whether it is real or not. You are ignorant, and until you have more knowledge on the topic, or have gone through what those of us who suffer from lyme daily, then be respectful and shut your mouths. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but you need to learn when it is time to back off.
And to go along with what hope said, it is not like I don't go through a single day wishing that I wasn't sick. I'm a college student with a part time job who is too sick to make it to most of her classes because she can't get the rest or help she needs medical wise. Every day I wish that I could be a "normal" college student. I am in a constant fight to show my teachers and those around me that, even though I am struggling so much, I can still graduate college without having to take time off or take less classes a term. And yet, unlike most of you, I go through everyday with a smile on my face. It's really hard sometimes, but I do not want others to know that each push forward is killing me inside. I'm not going to give up with trying to fight this illness, and I'm not going to let any of you cynics get in my way.
rerae, what you've said simply makes you a walking advertisement for the desperate need for universal health insurance. That way, you can go to the doctor who you need to see (rheumatologist) who can do a far better job of finding your proper diagnosis, and then help you to manage it.
The number of meds tools for managing auto-immune illnesses are increasing by leaps and bounds, because they are the direct result of the research being done into the genetics of auto-immune problems. And meds are not the only management tools available to anyone.
Medical management tools are the first step. THe second is being able to cure, and the third and final is being able to prevent. That's where the research is going.
iInd a way to see a rheumatologist. Seeing one in a teaching hospital-based clinic is your best bet.
I have seen a few rheumatologists. They have checked me for many different things. You don't know my situation, or any of these others situations. Just because it has not been completely uncovered yet, doesn't mean lyme doesn't exist. You have your opinion as I have mine. Don't sit here and tell me what you believe is best for me when you don't even know me, or my case.
For those of you that hate allopathic doctors, please stop coming. I am not an egomaniac but bound by ethics to not sell you something I cannot support with current medical literature. Please stick to your snake oil salesmen, hopefully they at least make you feel better as I often cant as ethics keep me from telling you anything other than what current medical literature would support. Most folks keep going to the doctor until they hear what they want, or someone who justifies their dysfunction, or "listens" to them. I can do that but refuse to sacrificee my personal ethic to make a dollar. But please help yourself if that is who make you feel better.
I suspect that the "doubters" amongst the General Public and amongst the Doctors are NOT CONSIDERING the Immunology of the body when expressing their skepticism.
Once infected with some microorganisms, an Auto-Immune disease ensues...which will most likely last for the person's entire life and will require regular treatment in order to keep the disabling symptoms at bay.
I am NOT a Doctor...but I have had Auto-Immune disease for 25 years.(NOT Lyme Disease)I believe that I know a little bit about some of this.
It is naive and counter-productive to dismiss "chronic" Lyme Disease as non-existent. Ask ANY qualified Immunologist.
more than 90 percent of doctors know and believe chronic lyme disease exists they are just in fear of being brought the to medical board for treating it so they choose to ignore it.
the people on this thread who are trying to deny lyme need to learn how to read and then do some.
Paul
Ms. Diane Bradley Washington are you there?
Weird. I just heard from a friend, today, who I found is being treated for chronic Lyme. However, reading this article would convince ME that I had it! Who isn't fatigued and in some pain somewhere? Could someone please be really specific about the symptoms? I know about fibro and CFS-WAY more than I want to know. And I've been bitten by lots of ticks. But I've never noticed a rash.
You really have no idea.
Are you in significant pain. Do you need pain meds or psychotropics to make it through the day? Do these meds not really work for you anyway?
Were you highly functional one day, and caught some kind of flu-like illness that never went away.
Can you work? Can you drive a car? If so, can you drive a car without feeling lost?
Do you have terrible insomnia that can last for many days no matter how tired you may be? Do you wake at 4 AM every night feeling very sick?
Do you ever feel like you are going to die, and this feeling lingers for days or weeks? I am not talking about a thought. A feeling.
Have you ever had panic attacks that last the whole day or several days? Have you ever been to the hospital with a heart rate of over 200 bpm that wouldn't come down without beta blockers (heart medication), anxiolytics, and pain medicine for angina? Have you ever shown up to a hospital with triage thinking you are having a heart attack? I have, at 24 years old.
Do you ever go partially functional for several days or weeks, and for the next week you can't get out of bed because of pain/discomfort?
Do you have significant chest pain all the time? I do. It's better than it used to be thank god. It would be nice if it goes away.
Do you have hundreds of thousands of dollars in medical bills, and tens of thousands of dollars of out of pocket expenses? Have you been to your primary care physician, neurologist, psychiatrist, opthamologist, rheumatologist, endocrinologist with no answers? I have.
Do you have mitochondrial dysfunction? Do you not convert oxygen to energy properly. I don't. My fitness profile is in the bottom 1% of the population, and I used to be a super athlete and mountain biked 30 miles a day in the Sierra Nevada mountains. Now I get winded walking up the stairs slowly.
I have both CFS and Chronic Lyme Disease, and yes, some doctors and researchers are finding that these two diseases may be linked (XMRV retrovirus). My CFS doctor at first thought that I really didn't have Lyme Disease and CFS. In fact, he told me he really didn't believe in Chronic Lyme Disease anymore (I am in TX).
I got a phone call back from the nurse saying that the doctor thinks I do in fact have Lyme Disease.
I think a majority of people with Chronic Lyme Disease may have the newly discovered CFS retrovirus (HIV is a retrovirus) as well. However, I think a number of infections can trigger CFS.
I am much better than I was, but unfortunately I am not well. I have to live with my parents now as I still can't drive a car or work. I gave my car to my older sister.
Now that being said, if you met me and I didn't tell you anything, you probably couldn't guess that I am sick. I can walk, talk, and look otherwise normal. I go out when I feel ok enough to do so, but in reality I am suffering and feeling symptoms all the time.
You obviously don't know anything about CFS, Fibro, or Lyme. There are many that are bed or wheelchair bound. You won't see the most serious cases, because those people can't leave their room for a number of reasons (neurological, sensitivity to any stimulation, severe pain, etc).
Why don't you just thank god that you have your health. Some of us are not so fortunate. I am 24, and these ARE NOT aches and pains of daily living. Step back and have compassion for others. You can't even compare yourself to others with these conditions, so please don't try.
Kyle:
I truly understand your maladies and the pain you endure everyday. I have utmost Empathy for you as you are so young & must live the rest of your life with such. I just now posted my history and am with you on those who are healthy to Thank God each day they are.
I'm beginning to see that the younger generation is more apt to help me open the heavy doors that doctor's use, which I do not understand. I had one young nurses aid who helped me with my scooter as I was at my Breast Specialist & it was sunny when I went in, but was storming when I came out. I tried to wait the storm out, but the pain was getting to severe & knew I had a 40 mile drive home. The wind was blowing my umbrella wrong side out.
This young lady told me to hold onto my umbrella & step back with my rollator. She was a very thin young lady; however, she didn't mess with the remote control. She just picked up my scooter and put it in the back of my van and took off down the hill to the employees parking lot. I was so upset I didn't see her name tag. There are lots of doctor's offices &a surgical center in the lower floor of this building. I would say she was in her young 20's.
It's my generation (the baby boomers) who just look at me & don't even try to help me open doors. I carry a small cane with a handle on it to try to open the doors; however, it's getting to the point where I call the office & tell them I'm at the door & to please send someone to open it.
Wish a healthy person could just spend one full day 'in our shoes' and I'm sure their thinking and their life would be changed for the betterment of those who are severely handicapped.
Will add you to my morning & evening Prayers as I've come to realize that Prayers are quite Mighty. God Bless you Kyle.
Kyle, sorry, I didn't mean to sound unfeeling. I was just expressing that the symptoms listed were very general. As a sufferer of severe chronic migraines I am not indifferent to pain and suffering. Without my preventive meds (2 anti convulsants) I would likely be in bed in a dark room every day. As it is I still have a migraine to some degree every day. I also have fibromyalgia, which means my whole body hurts every day. I can't take NSAIDS for fear of rebound headaches, which I have experienced-it's better just to stretch and do relaxation exercises for the pain. I also don't take narcotics due to being a recovering alcoholic. There are days when I can hardly move-like you, no one can see anything wrong with me, so there is no sympathy at all. Without meds I don't sleep at all, period. Since the mind can't go without sleep, I start to lose it after about 3 nights. I have had a positive test for narcolepsy some years ago, though the doctor questioned whether it was valid. I still sleep more than 12 hours-some days I'm only up for about 5 hours or so. I also have neurological problems-my neurologist thinks I have a neuropathy, though nothing has ever shown up. I gave up talking to doctors about all of this long ago-I'm doing well to have a doctor who believes fibromyalgia exists. Can't tell you how many docs have thought things were all in my head, even in the ER. Once I was denied not only treatment but also food and water for 48 hours in the hospital when I had a spinal headache from a spinal tap received in their ER. My own family doesn't believe I'm sick. So I'm sorry if I came across as not caring. I didn't mean to.
P.S. The last time I showed up at the hospital with a heart problem (PVC's) they just shoved me into the back of the ER and left me alone all night without even monitoring me. After 6 hours when I fell asleep they did an EKG which picked up nothing, then they sent me home. I discovered later that I do have an anomaly in my valve which causes the PVC's.
Just a few more additions. Kyle, I really do feel for you. Believe it or not I have seen a lot of people like you, as I was once team leader of a chronic pain/industrial rehab center. So I have seen extreme amounts of disability due to pain and fibromyalgia. No one discussed chronic lyme back then. I never thought I would wind up in their shoes! At least I do have a good bit of knowledge of how to self treat and make myself as functional as possible. Part of me is probably jealous that you have doctors that actually listen to you and take you seriously. I have to walk on eggshells around the docs I have b/c too often I've had docs who were fine turn on me and suddenly start offering Xanax for everything from fevers to coughs. That's when I know I have to find another doc. At that point they will never investigate anything or do any testing or anything b/c they've made up their minds that everything, and I mean everything is all in my head.
That seems to be a trend these days. My husband says his PA treats him that way, and he's never had a psychiatric problem or taken an antidepressant in his life! It seriously ticks me off! I know there's a connection between mind and body and all that, but EVERYTHING is not all in your head. I wonder if they do that b/c they're too lazy to do testing. I've just given up and pretty much keep it all to myself.
Thanks for your replies. Sorry that I misinterpreted your post. I thought you were just one of the common folks bashing people with these diseases/syndromes.
Sorry about that, and I definitely know what you mean about doctors using Xanax for everything.
When I ended up in the hospital after I got ill, I usually ended up on Ativan with a suggestion to see a psychiatrist. It didn't matter that my heart reached over 200 bpm, and stayed over 100 bpm while sedated to sleep in the ER. Most doctors really just don't care.
I'm lucky to have a team of doctors that listens to me without trying to pull a new psychiatric diagnosis out of their hat. Sure, I have anxiety, and it used to be terrible. It was the worst anxiety my doctor has seen in his career (and he was an older doctor). However, most doctors still don't understand that severe anxiety like I had was the consequence of a disease state, not because of my mind.
I went 15 years with all kinds of symptoms & visited doctor after doctor who told me it was all in my head. As a child from 10 until 20 yrs. of age,we went camping every weekend. Yes, tick bites galore. I've never had any Lyme tests completed. Those tests were unheard of in our backward State. However, I finally went to a Diagnostic Clinic in 1990 & was diagnosed with Severe Fibromyalgia.
I'm 56 years old & recv'd my SSD in 2006 with Judge awarding my disability back to Oct. 2004. Since then, I've had 7 surgeries on my spine (cervical and lumbar) due to crumbling spine & osteophytes (bone spurs) all over my spine. One in my cervical area pushed on a disk & caused the matter to be hanging over my other disks. A simple X-ray showed such. Thus one surgery was a Posterior Laminectomy of 4 disks & decompression of the cervical spine - worst surgery & pain of all my surgeries.
My dxs by my Neurosurgeon is Severe Degenerative Disk & Joint Disease, Severe Osteoarthritis & Arachnoiditis, Permanent Nerve Damage in Left Leg/Foot and 100% Disabled. He doesn't believe in Fibromyalgia; however he prescribed Lyrica for severe peripheral Neuropathy. When Lyrica hit the market it was only for Diabetic Neuropathy. Then advertised for the PN & now is advertised for Fibromyalgia relief.
Have a Spinal Cord Stimulator implanted because of Arachnoiditis, which in layman's term is a cobweb of nerve roots. Every year more nerves are being added to the cobweb. Now I am inoperable on my lumbar spine. I cannot walk without the use of a rollator (walker with large wheels,hand brakes, & seat) in the house or a scooter for use when away from home, which Medicare would not pay for either.
I'm unable to do any housecleaning including washing clothes as my hands will not allow me to remove the clothes from the washing machine. I can load our dishwasher, altho it takes me about 3 hrs. to do so & take clothes out of the dryer. Any type of tasks takes a long time to complete. Although at times my mind is sharp as a tack & other times I cannot remember squat. Short term memory is almost completely gone. I was an Accountant before being disabled & continue to pay our bills (never overdrawn our checking account) & complete tax returns for ourselves and my husband's family.
As my husband is a Long Haul Truck Driver I'm alone at least 5-6 days out of the week. Because of all the pain pills (including morphine) my Neurosurgeon & Pain Management Doctor rx'd over the 5 years ago, I'm just began seeing a Neurologist whose is running brain tests (No MRI due to Spinal Cord Stimulator) so they are Cat Scans, EMGS & brain monitoring for a week. I will know results this Wednesday. I want off these pain pills because it also crumbled my teeth in an 8 mth. period. Oral surgeon removed my all my teeth in 2 surgeries. Before I could get my impressions made for my dentures, I was found to have bone spurs all across my upper and lower gum line. Thus, another surgery in Sept. 3 months of anesthesia takes a toll on a normal person, much less one whose immune system is so suppressed.
We live in a very small town (pop. 2,401) and is a long way to see doctors in a major city. The day before I need to drive to see my doctors, I quit taking all my meds. I end up going 1 1/2 days w/o them & yes the withdrawal symptoms occur, like sweating, nausea, etc. Van is equipped with a remote control lift to easily remove my scooter. Medicare would only pay for a regular wheel chair.
Because of the severe osteoarthritis my hands & feet (with 3 toes on left foot that will not move)look like a person with rhuematoid Arthritis. I'm right handed & it is the worse. So manual wheelchair is of no use to me. I wear Depends (going thru 4-7 a day) because I've lost bladder control and the Urologist I saw wanted to put a TVT sling in Dec. 2008. I just happened to see a FDA Warning on msnbc.com on Oct. 19,2008 warning the new slings for bladder & hernia operations was made with a petroleum based product causing them to dry up & move into other organs in your body & causing severe pain & many removal surgeries, as once dried up..not easy to find. I called to set up appt. at end of 10/08 & was told I could get appt. 2 days before surgery. Cancelled everything and requested records.
My husband is trying to look for a job within a 75 mile radius of our home; however, as all know jobs are hard to come by. He is 54(at age 50 had 5 bypass surgery & in less than 4 mths. needed a pacemaker implanted) & truck driving is the only job he's held besides being a truck dispatcher for 7 1/2 yrs.
So I don't care what you write, Lyme Disease is real and as you get older the disease causes all kinds of other maladies. I'm a Living Example of what it can cause. You can debate all my issues (which will just be consonants & vowels to me) all you want; however, until you 'walk in my shoes' you don't know the facts.
IMPORTANT FACTS: This article below documents the available evidence supporting both the existence of Chronic Lyme Disease, as well as the persistence of the infection despite antibiotic therapy. The abstracts are available on U.S. Government's Public Medical Database [pubmed.gov].
The Case For Chronic Infection: Evidential persistence of Borrelia species post antibiotic exposure in vivo and in vitro.
Click Link To Read The Case For Chronic Infection: https://acrobat.com/#d=sbb-EmpQrQTgrPoezLGreg
Reuter's article is misleading, suggesting that only a "small" group of doctors in Connecticut recognize the disease, but the reality is that physicians around the world are quietly treating and diagnosing Chronic Lyme Disease, including in many countries: Germany, Brazil, UK, Mexico and every state in the United States. There are thousands of physicians treating this infection, but this survey was only performed in Connecticut.
Few doctors in Connecticut would dare treat or recognize Chronic Lyme Disease unless they want to end up like Charles Ray Jones. Many physicians I've spoken to cite his trial as a primary reason that they avoid going public about their involvement, or getting involved at all with this controversial condition. Even with a new law in place to protect physicians, they know as well as I do that there are other ways to skin a physician who decides to treat outside the guidelines of the IDSA. Dr. Jones was the perfect example. They didn't nail him to the cross because he used long term antibiotics. They did it claiming he prescribed and diagnosed a patient by telephone. Physicians I've spoken to tell me "They don't have to take away my license because I treat Lyme Disease long term, they can accuse me of something totally unrelated and still achieve the same goal of stripping me of my ability to treat patients."
Hard to argue with those facts, am I right?
Now the reality is, the evidence is abundant suggesting the infection dose persist. That's the truth. You can use "facts" to obscure the truth, and you can report doctors to state medical boards for treating this condition, but this epidemic is spreading whether you wish to recognize that or not.
Let's look at a few quotes from studies published in well respected peer-reviewed journals that support my statements regarding persistence.
"We conclude that the treatment of Borrelia burgdorferi (Lyme Disease) with appropriate antibiotics for even more than 3 months may not always eradicate the spirochete." - Ann Med. 1999 Jun; 3,3:225-32.
"The Lyme disease spirochete, can be recovered long after initial infection, even from antibiotic-treated patients, indicating that it resists eradication by host defense mechanisms and antibiotics".- 1:20 J Infect Dis. 1992 Aug;166,2:440-4
This new method for culturing B. burgdorferi from patients with chronic Lyme disease certainly defines the nature of the illness and establishes that it is of chronic infectious etiology." - Infection. 1998 Nov-Dec; 26,6:364-7
"These data demonstrate that Lyme neuroborreliosis is a persistent infection."- Ann Neurol. 2001 Sep;50,3, :330-8
"In one of the six analysed brain tissue specimens [from a patient that received more than six months of antibiotic treatment prior to death, including two 3-week courses of IV ceftriaxone], B. burgdorferi DNA was detected by PCR." - Brain. 1996 Dec;119, Pt 6:2143-54
"Two hundred seventy-seven patients with chronic Lyme disease were treated with tetracycline for 1 to 11 months, These results support the use of longer courses of treatment in the management of patients with chronic Lyme disease." - Clin Infect Dis. 1997 Jul;25 Suppl 1:S52-6.
I have more than 100 studies just like these above. They can't all be wrong, now can they?
You're right, but as the ILADS doctors noted, the IDSA has financial ties to companies that treat symptoms rather than cure Lyme.
A lot of diseases and conditions don't exist until the drug companies create a very expensive pill or vaccine for it. Then the doctors are rushing to tell you that you have this condition. The problem with chronic lyme disease is that the drug companies have not found a pill for it yet, once they do, it will be recognized and treated, and then everyone will have the disease. Doctors and drug companies don't make money off people that are healthy.
I was treated for over 3 years with "chronic lyme" including by one to the top "Lyme" docs in Conn. After being blasted and sickened by antibiotics without improvement I looked elsewhere. Thank you Ritchie Shoemaker in Maryland for finding my house and body was full of toxic mold. He used just a bit more science than just treating me symptomatically to diagnosis me with mold illness. During my time in the "Lyme" community I found many people who were chronically ill. I felt many of these people where married to their disease. I refused to be married to my illness and sought out help in other areas which led me to Shoemaker. My house is now clean and my body while still recovering is much better.
RIGHT ON! HARVEY! My son and I were full of mold, mercury & other additives from vaccines. etc. That made us horrifically sick in addition to the poisons from Lyme & co-infections!
We were detoxed via www.AdvancedCellTraining.com -ACT, which worked amazingly~And have had long term involvement in the process. Even to address the emotional trauma caused by the lack of help as well as personal struggles!
After being poisoned by the heparin from China, which killed thousands, I could no longer try antibiotics, they were now poison. My son, too, could only take so much of the antibiotics before he had an adverse reaction!
The ionic foot bath does great...you actually see the flakes of heavy metal.